Beautiful Beautiful Butt Plugs: Guide to the 70 Best

Butt Plugs for the people, by the people.  This post lets you vote for your favorite butt plugs from a list of 70 different (which continues to grow).  Of course, everyone's needs are different, so a butt plug that works for you might not work for everyone else, but it's still a fun way to let your butt be heard and discover some awesome butt plugs.

After the list, you’ll find some other guides on how to use butt plugs and how to do anal training.

Butt Plug Safety and Materials

Flared Base - When looking for a butt plug, it's important to use something with a flared base.  This will prevent the toy from getting stuck inside you, and help you avoid and embarrassing ER trip to have doctors remove it using tools.

Material - Some good butt plug materials include medical-grade (aka platinum cure) silicone, glass, polished stone, ceramic and stainless steel.  These are all body-safe, non-porous, and easy to clean.

Avoid materials like PVC, Jelly, TPE, and TPR.  These can contain toxic chemicals (there's no regulations on sex toys), and are also porous which means they will suck up bacteria and be impossible to completely clean, which is never good when it comes to sex toys.

Best Tail Plugs

Tail shaped butt plugs can be controversial depending on where you get them.  It's important to use either synthetic fur, or fur that isn't harvested just for the sake of butt plugs.  

Crystal Delights makes the rabbit tail plug that uses fur from rabbits that are found dead in the wild.  They also donate a portion of the profits to protecting wildlife. And the tail is also magnetic so you can use the glass plug by itself, or switch with other magnetic tails.

Best Inexpensive Butt Plugs

My pick for the best butt plug under $20 is the Hole Punch by hole punch studios.  It's $19 and uses platinum cure medical-grade silicone, one of the cheapest butt plugs with such high quality material.

People lately started to use butt plugs more and more and here are some examples that show why and how they do it:

  • First of all we are talking about increased sex pleasure. These cool toys can be used for self- pleasure or during sex if you are a couple. A woman with a butt plug in doggy style can look pretty enough to make the man horny and increase the sex pleasure as a couple.
  • Some females use and enjoy butt plugs for double penetration, or to feel also anal pleasure during vaginal masturbation.
  • Anal orgasm can be easily reached with an anal plug. The orgasm may not be as intense as a vaginal one but still, it is an orgasm.
  • Men with a prostate to stimulate can experience an even a more intense orgasm with it.

It is crucial that you keep pleasuring yourself or yourselves in a way that will let you stay safe. There are two factors that you need to consider when using a butt plug in a safe way:

  • The flared base is of huge importance if you don’t want accidents to happen. This will keep the toy reachable and you will be able to take it out. Losing a toy inside is not an option at all. No one wants to get to the hospital with this kind of problems, at least.
  • Another thing that you should be aware of when buying a butt plug is the material. You need to make sure the material that the toy is made off will not break inside you and cause damage. The most common materials are: proper annealed metal, glass, silicone, stainless steel and even wood. Feeling comfortable with it also counts.

We can talk now a little bit about how to use an anal plug. As we all know, in anal sex you need a lot of lubricant. The rectum doesn’t produce it by itself. Before inserting a toy in it, you need to be sure that you have enough lubricant. You can use silicone lubricant for toys that are not made from silicone and lubricant based on water for toys that are made from silicone. A little foreplay can definitely work.

Do not go straight ahead with the toy. Try lubricate your finger, rub a little bit the entrance, an after that insert it inside. You definitely need to be relaxed, feel good and ready for this. After inserting one finger you can introduce an additional one and when you feel it is large enough, you should try the toy.

Cleaning is also very important. Nonporous materials are a great choice because they can be boiled to make sure there is no germ left. For some toys it works with water and soap. You will definitely not use a toy for vaginal pleasure after anal. You need to clean it first and you need to wash your hands also. If the butt plug still has some germs from anal use you can get pretty bad infections if you use it in vagina. It is also highly recommended not to pass your anal toy to somebody else. Do not, at any circumstances, share your butt plug with another man or woman. The risk of giving or receiving illnesses is too high. Using a condom can keep the germs away.

We would like to show you now a list of best anal plugs for girls and for boys:

Pride butt plug LGBT

is a beautiful toy, wonderful colored and with the flared base in shape of a heart. With a fair price, this one is a great starter, ideal for beginners because it is not too big(only 3.2 inches are there to insert), it has a pretty look, and it is made of 100% waterproof silicone.

Pros:

  • It is a cheap toy
  • It has 3.2 inches to insert so is not too big
  • It is not heavy

Cons:

  • Only water based lubricants required
  • Njoy Pure Plug Medium is one of those butt plugs that stay in. It is made of stainless steel so you can boil the toy in order to sanitize it, it has a ring flared base, and it is pretty good for beginners because it is not a large toy. The ring flared base is ideal for people with naughty fetishes and makes the toy easy to use.
  • Pros:
  • The stainless steel is easy to clean;
  • It has plenty of reviews so you can learn from other’s experiences;
  • Easy to use, due to its ring flared based.

                     Cons:

  • It can be a little bit heavy;
  • It is quite expensive.

 

  • Laid B.1 Stone Plug is a plug made out of stone. The cons of this product would be that it is a little bit expensive and heavy. On the other hand, the fact that it is made of stone can help when reaching orgasm. The plug is not too big, though, so it can be easily used by people that find themselves at the beginning of anal stimulation.

Pros:

  • The strong material will intensify the orgasm;
  • It is easy to clean.

                     Cons:

  • It can be a heavy plug, especially for beginners;
  • This plug is expensive, especially for a starter.
  • The hole bunch Is a set of toy in the shape of vegetables. They are in number of three and they are made out of silicone. But on the other hand, you will get 3 cute toys that are not heavy and you can wear them all day if you are into that. They are a little bit expensive but you get all three vegetables at this price. This set of toys is great for people that love role play.
  • Pros:
  • The set is cheap when you think you get the three of them at that price;
  • They are not heavy;
  • The set is ideal for role play;
  • The toys are perfect for beginners.

Cons:

  • No silicone lubricants can be used.
  • The copy of hole punch cj hooker silicone dildo green is a dildo made by human hand that is a little bit expensive for a silicone toy. On the other hand, it is a butt plug that will stay in so this is one of the best butt plugs to wear all day. The insertable length is somewhere around 13 cm(5.25”), so this is a big one.
  • Pros:
  • It is an easy toy;
  • It is not too big so it can be used by people with low experience in anal stimulation;

Cons:

  • The butt plug can be a little bit too expensive for a silicone toy;
  • You can use only lubricants based on water;
  • Piky is a sex toy that has a pokemon tale and it is made of body-safe silicone. This interesting shape is especially for role play and anime fetishes. It is actually a cute toy and that pokemon tail will stay outside.
  • Pros:
  • It’s a short and easy toy, pretty ok for beginners;
  • Ideal for people with role play as a fetish;

Cons:

  • It has a long tail which means the toy cannot be attached to a harness;
  • The material is silicone, so only water based lubricants are recommended.
  • Tristan 1 silicone butt plug by vixen - purple is a plug that can be easily worn all day long. It is not a heavy toy and it is not too big. It’s great as an anal training plug and it can be your sleep partner if you are the type sleeping with butt plugs.
  • Pros:
  • The flared base of this plug fits perfectly between butt cheeks;
  • It is a short and easy plug;

Cons:

  • Only water based lubricants;
  • Octopus anal toy is a butt plug with an octopus tale. It’s a cute anal toy and this can be the best starter butt plug. It comes in two sizes, small and large. It is not heavy and some may consider this the best anal plug for men. It is made of body-safe silicone.
  • Pros:
  • It’s a cute anal plug with a flared base that makes it attachable to a harness;
  • It has two sizes so it can be used by people with any kind of experience;
  • It is easy so you can wear this plug for hours.

Cons:

  • The toy is a bit expensive;
  • Silicone lubricants are out of the question.
  • Hole punch silicone butt plug - orange is a toy that comes in the shape of a bullet. You can insert it easy with plenty of lubricant and it is ideal for people that find themselves new in anal stimulation with plugs.
  • Pros:
  • It is a cheap toy;
  • It is ideal for beginners;
  • It will stay put, once inserted.

Cons:

  • No silicone lubricants recommended;
  • Bingo rainbow is an ingenious toy that has different shapes from the top to the bottom as it increases progressively. If you extract it properly you can experience an increased intense of orgasm. The toy can be used by beginners and by experienced people as well.
  • Pros:
  • It’s shape can intensify orgasm;
  • Ideal for people with different kind of experience;

Cons:

  • You can use only water lubricants;
  • It can be quite expensive.
  • Fragaria is a luxurious toy made for people with large pockets. This gorgeous butt plug is made of brass and silver plated. It has a beautiful strawberry shape. If you respect yourself or your partner and of course, if you afford it, this could be a really nice and kinky present.
  • Pros:
  • It is a luxurious sweet piece;
  • It’s not too big so it can be used by beginners.

Cons:

  • The material can be a little heavy;
  • You can experience some difficulties in cleaning it;
  • The price is really high.
  • Magnetic white bunny tale is an anal plug made of pyrex glass with a rabbit fur at the bottom. The tail can easily be removed so if you don’t feel like wearing a bunny tail, you simply don’t have to. You can enjoy the tail plug instead.
  • Pros:
  • It is a wonderful piece for people enjoying role play;
  • The tail is detachable;
  • It can be used by experienced people and beginners as well.

Cons:

  • The material is delicate;
  • The price can be pretty high.
  • Ice cram cone is a sweet toy that has a three colored ice-cream shape. Once in, this anal plug will stay in. We recommend it for people with some experience in anal play due to its wide shape.
  • Pros:
  • It is an interesting ice-cream shaped toy;
  • It will stay put, once inserted.

Cons:

  • It is quite expensive;
  • Beginners can find it difficult to use;
  • No silicone lubricants recommended.
  • Etna anal stimulator is another luxurious anal plug with the Mount Etna as its flared base. This is another toy for people that can afford expensive toys. This one is made of brass with 24ct gold above which makes of it a wonderful present for you or your partner.
  • Pros:
  • The plug plated with gold can be a sweet present;
  • Its shape is ideal for all levels of experience.

Cons:

  • It is an expensive anal plug;
  • It can be hard to clean.
  • Coco de mer is a beautiful butt plug with a cute print on the bottom. It is made of ceramic. The product it is quite expensive. People with any kind of experience can use it as long as they are careful with the material.
  • Pros:
  • It is a plug for both men and women regardless of their experience;
  • It has a very pretty look.

Cons:

  • The toy is kind of expensive;
  • The material is delicate.
  • Rose bud glass is an interesting butt plug with a silicone head and its wide size increasing and decreasing from the head to the flared base. The toy will make you experience an intense orgasm. Due to its shape, it can be used by people that are at a higher level of experience and by beginners as well.
  • Pros:
  • The shape is made for intensifying the orgasm;
  • Beginners and experienced people can equally use it.

Cons:

  • The material is delicate;
  • It is not a cheap toy.
  • Mini root is a small and cute anal toy with an interesting surface. It is made of body safe silicone and it has 3.5 inches that can be inserted. It is not a heavy butt plug so you can wear it easily under clothes as much as you want to. We cannot say for sure that it is the most comfortable toy, but it is definitely an anal plug that will give you intense orgasms.
  • Pros:
  • Interesting and realistic surface;
  • It will intensify anal orgasm and G-spot stimulation;

Cons:

  • Silicone lubricants are not allowed.
  • Batt plug is a sex toy made of body safe silicone with 3.5 inches that can be inserted. It ends with a batman flared base. It is not too long or too heavy. This toy can serve as a great anal plug for beginners. Your fetishes will come to life with this plug ideal for role play.
  • Pros:
  • The big pro is its flared based in batman shape. It makes it great for role play;
  • Both beginners and experienced people can use it.

Cons:

  • Silicone doesn’t let you to use anything else but water based lubricants.
  • The broad city ass of an angel silicone butt plug is not a giant dildo, but a big enough one to make you feel real anal orgasms. It has 5 inches to be inserted and it’s made of silicone. This is a gorgeous, colored anal plug, both for men and for women.
  • Pros:
  • Men and women can equally use it;
  • It is a cheap plug;

Cons:

  • It should be lubricated only with water lubricants.
  • Avant pride p6 beyond silicone butt plug is a sweet silicone toy ideal for singles or couples. It is long enough to make you feel pleasure even if you have some experience with anal plugs, and it has a nice flared base that will stay gorgeous between your butt cheeks. You can easily wear this toy as long as you feel comfortable.
  • Pros:
  • Confortable flared base that will make the toy stay inside for hours;
  • Ideal for starters and experienced people as well.

Cons:

  • No silicone lubricants allowed
  • Hole Punch Butnik Silicone Butt Plug it is an interesting anal toy with a cock ring in the middle. This is an ideal toy for a couple or if you want to surprise your sex partner with such an interesting novelty. It has something for both of you.
  • Pros:
  • The cock ring is a plus so this toy is ideal for both partners in a couple;
  • Wonderful for G-spot and prostate stimulation;

Cons:

  • Only water lubricants can be used.
  • Funkit toy is a handmade silicone butt plug with a flared base that can be attached to a harness. This toy can be easily used by women and by men, for both vagina and ass. Prostate and clitoris stimulation could benefit from using this plug.
  • Pros:
  • It is ideal for any kind of stimulation;
  • It is not very expensive;
  • It can be attached to a harness.

Cons:

  • Lubricants based on silicone shouldn’t be used.
  • Fun Factory B Ball is a toy that people could say it is best rated for beginners. It is not too long. It is a small and easy toy. With its interesting flared base, you can wear this anal plug as long as you wish. You can insert it 3 inches so this toy is good for all levels of experience. Plus, its ball will roll in you and will bounce with every move you make, so you will definitely feel it inside.
  • Pros:
  • It has a pink ball included that will make you feel each and every move you make reaching responses inside you;
  • Ideal for every kind of experience;
  • Its flared base will make the toy wonderfully fit between your butt cheeks.

Cons:

  • Only the silicone material that can be lubricated with water based lubricants.
  • Buddy silicone has an interesting shape, made for prostate as well as for G-spot stimulation.  It is a cute top butt plug that can be used by both female and male regardless of their experience.
  • Pros:
  • It is a great plug for you if you are a starter and even if you have experience in anal stimulation with plugs;
  • It is not an expensive toy;
  • It will bring wonderful feelings and intense orgasms to both men and women.

Cons:

  • Lubricants based on silicone cannot be used.
  • Randy the Raccoon is a sweet tail plug that will be your best companion in role play. The material is stainless steel so you can boil it and clean it very easily. It is not too heavy and definitely not a giant toy so this butt plug can easily be one of the best wearable butt plugs.
  • Pros:
  • It is a good plug for role play due to its tail;
  • It is not too big so it can be used by boys and girls with any kind of experience;
  • It is easy to clean.

Cons:

  • The material can be a little bit heavy to wear all day or night.
  • Fun Factory Bootie is one of the best rated toys out there. Made of silicone, this anal plug has an interesting base for extended wear. It’s a large toy, so this one is perfect if you have some experience in anal stimulation. It can be easily used for stimulating the prostate as well.
  • Pros:
  • The plug can be used under clothes and with its flared base it fits idealy between the butt cheeks;
  • It is easy and the size is perfect for each level of experience;

Cons:

  • It is not recommended to use silicone lubricants.
  • The Mighty Moaning Anal Rangers is a series of anal plugs in large and small sizes so you don’t have to worry if you are a beginner. You can choose from different colors the one that suits you the best. Its surface will give a plus in orgasm intensity.
  • Pros:
  • It is a set with different sizes and colors;
  • The surface will intensify the feeling of orgasm;
  • It is easy and cheap.

Cons:

  • Silicone lubricants cannot be used.
  • Beginner silicone Phthalate Discreet Packaging  is an interesting training kit that you can find on Amazon with three different sizes: small medium and large. It is a wonderful set of toys for beginners but it’s great for experienced people as well. Enjoy your wonderful anal experiences with this cheap, yet good product based on the 5 star reviews it has.
  • Pros:
  • It has plenty of reviews so you can make your decision based on other peoples experiences;
  • It has different sizes so you do not have to worry if you are a starter;
  • It can easily intensify anal or vaginal orgasm.

Cons:

  • It is highly recommended not to use silicone lubricants.
  • Paloqueth silicone anal plug toy kit is a set of anal toys that has plenty reviews on amazon. This set serves great for women and men, intensifying orgasm for both. It is said that man can come to climax without using hands, so this set is definitely a must. It is a sweet training kit for anal stimulation.
  • Pros:
  • Beginners are welcome as well as experienced users;
  • Very confortable plugs that will be your partner for hours;
  • Made for both vaginal and anal orgasms.

Cons:

  • You cannot lubricate them with silicone.
  • AKStore 3 Pcs Luxury Jewelry Design Fetish Stainless Steel is another interesting set with a very good price. It is made of stainless steel so it is easy to clean. These toys can equally be used by men and women, couples or singles. You can wear them all day. The reviews of these toys speak for themselves.
  • Pros:
  • Plenty of reviews;
  •  Easy to clean material;
  • A great fit for any genre or experience.

Cons:

  • The material can be a little heavy, especially if you want to use it for hours.
  • AKStore Small Super Steel Fetish Plug is a sweet small toy that can fit easy and smooth inside your bum. You don’t have to worry that the material can break. It is a little bit heavier than most of the anal plugs out there so you will not forget that you have it inside you.
  • Pros:
  • It is a toy that will not let you forget about it if you wear it for hours;
  • It is not a long one so you do not have to worry if you do not have any experience;
  • The material is strong and will not break inside at any circumstances.

Cons:

  • The material can be a little heavy.
  • Bestimulus Wild Silicone Fox’s Tail is a plug made for people who love role play. It can be easy used for fashion purposes as well. It is a cute toy, fun to wear inside, and definitely a plug that will make you feel comfortable wearing it.
  • Pros:
  • It is a great butt plug for role play;
  • You can use it even as a training plug, due to its not too large size.

Cons:

  • Some people just don’t like the tail.
  • Beauty7 Rabbit Bunny Tail is an interesting kit of anal toys that is wonderful for beginners as well as for the experienced ones. The stainless steel plugs can be easily cleaned and used with any type of lubricants. The set comes with three toys of different sizes so don’t worry if you have some experience in anal stimulation. This kit is for everyone.
  • Pros:
  • The kit has bulb sizes for everyone;
  • The toys are easy to wear and they will they in, once inserted;
  • The bunny tail it’s a plus for those enjoying role play.

Cons:

  • As a con, some people may consider the material.
  • Baby Pink Crystal Minx Detachable Faux Pony Tail Plug is an interesting toy with a detachable pink pony tail. You need to be careful with this kind of material. The pony tail serves well for people who love role play. The plug is available in different sizes.
  • Pros:
  • The pony tail can be awesome in role play;
  • The toy is easy and can stay inside for as long as you want;

Cons:

  • The material is delicate;
  • The price is a little too high.
  • Grey Wolf Crystal Minx Faux Fur Tail Plug is another toy made of glass. It has a beautiful wolf tail that is designed for role play lovers. It can have a small, medium or a large bulb. So this one is also great for any kind of experience.
  • Pros:
  • The wolf tail can boost your imagination in role play;
  • It is easy so you can wear it for hours.

Cons:

  • The material is very delicate;
  • It is quite an expensive plug.
  • Aurora Borealis Crystal Mini-Twist Plug is a toy made for princesses with an interesting shape. It comes in two sizes and its flared base can be useful if you want to attach it to a harness. It can be used by beginners and people with experience in anal stimulation. Depending on the fetishes, it can be used by both male and female.
  • Pros:
  • It can be a sweet present for your princess;
  • It can be used by both boys and girls;
  • Can stay perfectly inside for as long as you want.

Cons:

  • It is made out of a pretty delicate material.
  • Black Colors Against Cancer Plug is a pretty anal toy that can serve as a wonderful sexual stimulator for girls and for boy as well. It is definitely a toy to wear under clothes. It will satisfy sexual fetishes for singles and for couples the same. The purchase of each of this toy will turn into a donation for different types of cancer.
  • Pros:
  • Buying this plug, you can help people with cancer;
  • The toy is easy to wear and will stay with you long enough to satisfy your kinky pleasures;
  • It has an interesting black color, ideal for men and women alike.

Cons:

  • The glass can be delicate.
  • Pineapple Delight Plug  is a sweet princess toy with a Glacier Blue Swarovski crystal. This is a beautiful plug in a shape of pineapple. Satisfy your fetishes with this butt plug that can be inside your for hours. It is easy to clean, and is handmade so don’t be surprised if this gorgeous piece doesn’t look exactly the same as the other ones of its type.
  • Pros:
  • It is a wonderful idea for a present;
  • It has unique surface that forms a pineapple. This will definitely intensify the orgasm;
  • It can be used for hours both by males and females.

Cons:

  • It is made out of glass, a delicate material.
  • Kink Signature 3” Silicone Butt Plug is a toy designed for both men and women with any level of experience. The toy has 2.5” to insert and can easily stimulate the prostate or the G-spot. It has a “Kink signature” on its flared base.
  • Pros:
  • This toy is ideal for stimulating the vagina and anus;
  • It is not a heavy plug so you can wear it with you anywhere you want to go;
  • It doesn’t matter if you are a beginner or experienced user. This toy is good for you.

Cons:

  • The con for this anal plug will be the fact that it cannot be lubricated.
  • As a conclusion, from this variety of plugs you can learn that there is something out there for everyone. No matter if you are looking for an expensive or cheap toy, for a tail plug or a toy without a tail, you will definitely find something that will please you. You can try to find a realistic material or a luxurious one. The most important thing is to be careful when you use it, put plenty of lubricant and enjoy your sexual stimulation by yourself or with your partner. Nothing will be the same in your sex life after the first anal experience.