13 Best Butt Plugs – Top Anal Toys For Unisex Pleasure!

By: JC Ways

Butt Plugs are common anal sex toys that are great for anal pleasure, prostate stimulation, roleplay, and warming up your bum before anal sex.

However, with so many different types of butt plug out there – glass, metal, silicone, animal tail – how do you know which anal plug is best for you?

Here we give you a rundown of the 13 best butt plugs on the market and answer all your questions about these fun anal toys.

Let’s get to it!

13 Best Butt Plugs


Black Jewelled Glass Butt Plug

This opulent bejeweled butt plug is a very sleek and sophisticated anal toy that can serve as a wonderful sexual stimulator for any gender. With 2.8 inches of insertable length, this glass plug is perfect for intermediate or beginner users.

Part of Crsytal Delights’ “Colors Against Cancer” range of products, the manufacturer will also donate toward a cancer charity when you buy this, so that’s nice.


  • Great for beginners or intermediate users, solid glass construction, opulent design, donation to cancer charity, one of the best butt plugs


  • The glass can be delicate, very stiff

Best Budget Butt Plug - Hole Punch

With an insertable length of 3 inches, this bright orange silicone butt plug is perfect for anyone who wants to try butt plugs for the first time.

Clocking in at less than $20, this cheap sex toy is a great introduction to anal play, even if you’re not a fan of the bright orange design.


  • cheap, great for those new to anal penetration, 100% silicone, non-porous body-safe material


  • Basic, bright orange color isn't everyone's thing

Pineapple Delight - Best Glass Butt Plug

The Pineapple Delight Plug boasts a lovely Glacier Blue Swarovski crystal inside. This is a beautiful plug in the shape of pineapple (kind of), leading to some bumpy and interesting sensations inside your bottom.

This handmade plug almost looks like something that should be displayed on a purple cushion in the Tower of London. I wonder if the Queen has one?


  • intense shape, lovely construction, unisex, one of the best butt plugs


  • glass is a little delicate, could be cheaper

Best Metal Butt Plug (NJoy Pure Plug)

The NJoy Pure Plug Medium is one of those butt plugs that stays in no matter what. It is made of stainless steel so you can boil it in order to sanitize it, it has a ring flared base, and it is pretty good for beginners because it is not too large.

It’s also an incredibly sleek and sexy design; it has that sort of “manly” sex product look about it. It’s like something that a kinky CEO would keep in his drawer. Christian Grey probably has one.

Make your own 50 shades fantasy! You know you want to.


  • easy to clean, sleek and sexy design, ring-pull for easy removal after play, best butt plugs for temperature play


  • very heavy, pricey, not ideal for all-day wear

Remote Control Vibrating Plug - Lovense Hush 2

The Lovense Hush 2 is a vibrating butt plug which can be controlled remotely via your smartphone if you have a Bluetooth and/or Wi-Fi connection. It’s one of the best butt plugs for long-distance couples.

With the app, you can give control to your partner from any location in the world, and the revolutionary spiral design on the neck is designed to keep lube trapped in your sphincter for hours. All-day wear galore!

Dimensions of Lovense Hush Toy


  • Remote control long-distance butt plug, 1.5 hours of use, 120 hours of standby time, USB charging, give someone control, vibrating plug


  • Hard to remove, pricey (but it is a remote-controlled vibrating butt plug, to be fair)

The Hole Bunch

The hole bunch is a set of anal toys in the shape of vegetables. I mean, who doesn’t want carrots and turnips up their ass? These silicone-based products are great for all-day wear, and they are admittedly a little bit cute to look at.

They’re on the pricey side, but you do get the whole set of 3 for the price, giving you multiple options for kinky and unique anal fun. It also has a pun name, and I have a guilty pleasure for those pun names.


  • cheap, not too heavy, silicone construction, great for fun roleplay


  • not compatible with silicone-based lube, a little silly

'Fluke' Dual-Purpose Silicone Butt Plug Dildo

This small silicone dildo/plug is a little bit expensive for a silicone toy, but with an insertable length of more than 5 inches, this is one fo the largest plugs on this list.

If you’re interested in this unique hybrid-style product and you want to try bigger butt stuff, this is the perfect solution for you.


  • could be used as dildo or a plug, large length, great for more experienced users


  • rather pricey

Piky, the Pikachu Tail Butt Plug

In case you didn’t grow up in the ‘90s like me, Piky is based on the tail of Pikachu, the Pokémon character, although I imagine they can’t officially say that for legal reasons.

This tail butt plug is ideal for geeky couples into anime role play. Ever secretly fancied doing an Ash and Pikachu roleplay? Well, now you can! I don’t judge. Maybe Psyduck can pop along too. PSSSYYYYYY!!!!


  • nostalgia and sexiness aligned, 100% silicone, fun and quirky


  • only safe with water-based lubricants

Fragaria Silver-Plated Strawberry Plug

Fragaria is a luxurious product made for people with plenty of spare cash. This gorgeous butt plug is silver-plated brass shaped into a sleek and sexy strawberry.

The price is too high for most of us, but if you can afford this, it’s definitely a great kinky gift. Cream, anyone? It’s like a sexy Wimbledon up in here.


  • suitable for beginners, silver-plated brass, cute and unique design, best butt plugs for rich people!


  • very expensive, hard to clean

Ass Cram Cone

As you can probably tell, the Ass Cram Cone is inspired by Neapolitan ice cream. While I get that the name is a pun, I personally find the idea of “cramming it in your ass” a bit unappealing!

Still, once it’s in, this butt plug will stay in firmly. We recommend it for people with some experience in anal play due to its wide-ish shape.

This plug has a brown tip, which maybe wasn’t the best color choice for an anal toy.


  • fun unique shape, stays in place very easily when inserted, brown tip could camouflage mess?


  • pricey, not for beginners due to shape

Etna Anal Stimulator

The Etna Anal Stimulator is a luxurious butt plug with Mount Etna erupting as its flared base. Why you would want an Italian volcano inside your bum is beyond me, but cool.

Another stupidly expensive plug, this Italian-inspired plug is made of brass with 24ct gold plating, so it’s not in the price range for most of us cretins.

Maybe Donatella owns one. It’s very Versace-looking.


  • high-class sexy present, good for all experience levels, gold-plated brass construction


  • pricey, hard to clean

Minx Detachable Faux Pony Tail Plug

This is an interesting product with a detachable pink pony tail. It’s a very campy/girly kind of toy, so it’s great for those who are into unicorns and rainbows. I think I might be their target market here.

Although this plug is super fabulous, the tail can be difficult to clean if you get it dirty, so make sure you’re careful during play.


  • great for pony or unicorn roleplay, stays in for a long time, fab design


  • material is a little "meh", can get tugged on if you're not careful

Grey Wolf Crystal Tail Plug

The Grey Wolf Faux Fur Tail Plug is another plug made of glass. It’s perhaps one of the more “macho” butt plug tails on this list, most closely resembling a wolf’s tail.

This plug can have a small, medium or a large bulb, which makes it really unique and versatile, allowing you to have a tail while using a butt plug size which suits you.


  • different sizes available, wear it for hours if you want, fun "masculine" wolf roleplay


  • delicate material, expensive

What is a Butt Plug?

A butt plug is a small anal sex toy that can be worn by any gender. As the name suggests, butt plugs are supposed to plug butt holes!

Most butt plugs have a tapered edge which gradiates out and then becomes a skinny neck. This helps the anus to “close” around the skinny neck, keeping the plug in place.

Butt plug safety

ALL anal-related toys, butt plugs included, should have a flared base that stops the plug from slipping inside your bottom by accident. ALWAYS use a ton of lube when playing anally!

Another thing that you should be aware of when buying a butt plug is the material. You need to make sure the material that the plug is made of will not break inside you and cause damage.

Many sexy toys (butt plugs included) are made from unsafe materials that are toxic to your body or let bacteria grow inside their porous surfaces.

The safest adult product materials are borosilicate glass, silicone, ABS plastic, and stainless steel. Avoid sexual products made from toxic materials like jelly rubber and soft plastic.

Why Do People Use Butt Plugs?

There are many reasons why people use butt plugs, but here are 5 of the most common:

  1. Increased sexual pleasure. Wearing a butt plug during sex (whether you’re a man or woman) can heighten the sensations of regular intercourse. Some plugs might also help to stimulate the prostate or G-spot.
  2. Double penetration. Those with vaginas may use butt plugs for “double penetration”, allowing them to experience both their vagina and their butt being filled at the same time.
  3. Discreet public play. Many anal plugs are small enough to be worn all day, so they’re a fun thing to wear as you go about your daily life, keeping your dirty little secret to yourself.
  4. Preparing for anal sex. Many people use butt plugs to pre-stretch their anus before they’re going to recieve anal sex, making the sex much more comfortable.
  5. It’s hot! For some people (myself included) the idea of being plugged up is really hot, especially if you’re wearing the plug out in public.

How to Use A Buttplug

You need a lot of lubricant for anal play, as the bottom doesn’t produce natural lubricant/fluid like the vagina or mouth.

Water-based lube is compatible with nearly all sex toys, so invest in plenty!

A little foreplay is ideal before any kind of anal play, so try teasing your hole with your lubed-up finger first. After inserting one finger, you can introduce an additional one to gently stretch out.

Relax and allow it to happen.

When you feel that your hole is relaxed and large enough, then you should try the plug SLOWLY. Insert the lubed-up plug slowly, stopping if it feels painful.

Removing a butt plug

Taking a butt plug out is difficult at the best of times. It’s essential to make sure that you’ve used plenty of high-quality lube, as this will make removal much easier.

Relax, give yourself time, and begin to putt the plug out very slowly. Give your anus time to relax and open up around the shape.

DO NOT just yank it out! It could take you a good 5 minutes, but the product will come out if you relax enough.

Best Butt Plugs Cum-clusion

It seems like there’s a butt plug out there for everyone, whether you’re into vanilla butt plugs, elegant glass pineapples, or unicorn tails. Personally, I’m super into the B Ball Uno!

What can I say? I love balls.

Whether you go for a medical-grade silicone plug or a toy made from stone… read the instructions, play safe, and use lots of the appropriate lube every time. Have fun!

Written by

JC Ways

Born into a family of avant-garde artists, JC Ways rebelled against conventional paths from an early age. After obtaining a degree in Gender Studies and Creative Writing, they embarked on a journey to challenge societal norms through their writing. Embracing the intersection of sexuality and identity, JC found their calling at Sextoycollective.com, where they can explore and celebrate the diverse spectrum of human pleasure. With a flair for eloquent prose and a keen eye for innovative products, JC elevates the discourse around sexual wellness, advocating for inclusivity and empowerment in every article they pen.

  • Angelia says:

    I like stuff like this

  • BB says:

    Can a man’s penis feel a woman’s vibrating anal plug?

    • JC Ways says:

      I’m not sure to be honest! I wouldn’t have thought so, but I’d be interested to see what you discover.

  • lenita hendricks says:

    love it.. turns me on..

  • Recent Blog Posts

    Jerkmate Games Review: A Look at the Best Interactive Cam Shows & Porn Games

    Looking to spice up your masturbation time? I hear ya. When you love watching cam shows while you slap your…

    Meet RoxxyDallas – StripChat’s Hall of Fame Cam Girl

    Ever played Have You Met? It’s simple, really. I’ll introduce you to one of StripChat’s sexiest cam models, RoxxyDallas, and…

    11 Cheap Cam Sites for free & low-cost cams [2024]

    Camgirls (especially good ones) can be expensive. And let’s face it… when you’re horny, you’re more likely to burn cash…

    Vibrations & More

    7 Things to Know About the Autoblow AI, Male Masturbation Toy Review

    With more men opening up to the idea of spicing things up with male masturbation toys, renowned brands have tried…

    10 Best FTM Sex Toys for Trans Men in 2024

    Finding the right FMT sex toys may feel like a mission impossible for trans men and transmasculine people. We’re not…

    13 Best Interactive Sex Toys in 2024

    I’ll just go out and say it – interactive sex toys are the best thing that has happened to the…

    25 Best Clit Vibrators For Women: Guide To Mini, Wand, and Sucking Clit Vibes

    37% of women need clitoral stimulation in order to orgasm. In fact, 64% of women use both clitoral and vaginal…

    5 Vibrating Panties to Rock Your World In Public [2024]

    Do you crave the thrill of a dangerous yet pleasurable public orgasm? If so, vibrating panties might be your new favorite…