Lube 101: The Science Behind Safe Lubricant Use & More

By: Sex Toy Collective Team

Medically reviewed by Sarah Melancon Ph.D

Ask anyone what type of lubes they use, and the answer will probably be K-Y Jelly or Astroglide. Even though lubes like K-Y are popular, people aren’t aware of their risky ingredients, which studies have shown can lead to infections, irritation, and increased STI susceptibility [1][6-13].

This guide will help broaden your lube horizons beyond K-Y and show you the best and healthiest lubes for the kinds of sex you enjoy most. You’ll also learn about the science behind lube, their ingredients, and how they work

Who uses lube?

  • 89% of MSM (men having sex with men) relationships in San Francisco use lube on a regular basis [2].  Lube is an absolute must for anal sex, where the body provides very little natural lubrication, without it, delicate rectal tissue is easily damaged and torn.
  • A survey of 1,021 women found that 20% had used lube within the last 30 days, and 65.5% had used it at least once in their lifetime [3].  For vaginas, lube can make sex more comfortable, fun, and pleasurable and decrease discomfort/pain.  If you are taking certain medication or experiencing anxiety, lube can help give a boost in times of dryness.  Also, every body is different and some people produce less natural lubrication than others.
  • A similar survey found 25% of men had used lube within the last 30 days, and 70% had used it at least once in their lifetime [4].

Chapter 1:

Lube Base Ingredients

The ‘base’ is the main ingredient in lubes, and there are 4 main kinds: water, plant-oil, silicone, and hybrid.  Other ingredients are added to the base to alter the thickness, add flavoring, or increase its shelf life.

Water-Based Lubes

These lubricants are around 95% water, and feel like the vagina’s natural lubrication (also mostly water).

Since water is inexpensive, so are water-based lubes, helping them make up 72.5% of all lube sales in 2015 [5].

Other ingredients are added to water lubes to make them thicker, adding a slippery feeling you can swirl in your fingers.  You’ll also find preservatives, humectants, and dispersants in most water-based lubes.

Some of these ingredients are very controversial.

Lubes like K-Y use petroleum derived ingredients like glycerin and preservatives like chlorahexide that recent studies have found can damage vaginal and anal tissues, leading to an increased risk of infections, STIs, and Irritation.

The companies stick with these ingredients because they are cheaper than healthy alternatives like seaweed extract and citric acid.


  • Inexpensive
  • Water soluble, easy to clean
  • Feels similar to the vagina’s natural lubrication


  • Some can contain risky ingredients
  • Evaporates quickly and needs frequent reapplication, especially for external use

Silicone-Based Lubes

Meet the silicones.  A lube family with truly super-lubricant powers. Unlike water, silicone ingredients don’t evaporate or absorb into the skin.

The result? A lube that keeps going and going and going. This lube can last your entire sex without needing reapplication.

It’s also completely impervious to water.  This makes it a pain to get off your hands, but let’s you reach a whole new level of shower sex possibilities.

Silicone lube is also inert, non-toxic, and hypoallergenic.  It doesn’t need preservatives, and is shown to be one of the safest and gentlest lubes ever applied to delicate tissue [6].

There’s a dark side to silicone lube, though.  It hates silicone rubber – a popular and expensive sex toy material.  As soon as they touch, the lube will warp and mangle your sex toy due to a reaction between the silicone in the lube and the silicone in the toy.


  • Very long lasting
  • Hypoallergenic, inert, and non-toxic; doesn’t absorb into the skin
  • No smell
  • Compatible with condoms, and usually the type of lube that comes on pre-lubricated condoms


  • Can warp and ruin sex toys made of silicone
  • Difficult to clean

Plant-Based Lubes

Plant-based lubes contain natural ingredients like coconut oil, cocoa butter, shea butter, and aloe vera.  They are all usually 100% organic and some of the most gentle personal lubricants on the skin.

Unlike water-based lubricants, these do not need added ingredients like thickeners, humectants, and many are naturally self-preserving and don’t need any added anti-microbial chemicals.

And because there is no water, these lubricants have no pH and no osmolality (more about these terms in the next section) which makes them extra safe on vaginal and anal tissues.

They are NOT compatible with latex condoms though, same goes for other oil-based lubricants.  The oil will cause the latex condom to warp and easily break.  However, they do work with condoms made of polyurethane.


  • Gentle and hydrating
  • Often 100% organic
  • Compatible with sex toys
  • Lasts longer than water-based lubes


  • Not compatible with latex condoms
  • Take longer to completely exit the body


When a water lube and a silicone lube meet, they make beautiful lube babies together called hybrid lubes.

The most popular hybrid is Sliquid Silk, which contains 12% silicone by volume.  These hybrids feel like water-based lubes, but last like silicone lubes.  They are also easier to clean up and can usually be used on silicone sex toys.

Household Lubes

Lubes around the house deserve a special mention.  These aren’t marketed for sex, but make good substitutes in a pinch.  It’s important that you only use safe lubes.

The best options for vaginal use are pure coconut oil or shea butter.  I would not recommend trying anything besides these two. Why? Due to the high absorption of vaginal tissue, whatever chemicals you put inside you can easily be absorbed into the blood stream [18].

These rules don’t apply to the penis, which is less delicate and only has mucosa tissue in the urethra.  Nonetheless, using highly acidic makeshift lubes or lubes with harsh preservatives has the potential to cause urethral irritation and burning.

Also, don’t forget that oil-based lubes like Coconut Oil will break latex condoms.

Safe Household Lubes

  • Coconut oil (NOT with latex condoms)
  • Shea butter (NOT with latex condoms)

AVOID (Dangerous for vaginal & anal tissue)

  • Vaseline
  • Anything with sugar in it (honey, whipped-cream, etc)
  • Water-based gels

Risky Lubes – Recently, lubes like K-Y, Gynol, Durex Play, and Astroglide have come under scrutiny for using petroleum-derived ingredients and harsh preservatives [1].

In some studies these lubes were shown to damage tissue and increase the risk of B.V., Yeast Infections, and lower the body’s natural STI defenses [7-13].  In light of the studies, the United Nations’ World Health Organization made an announcement recommending people avoid many water-based lubricants on the market [1].

To understand the controversies around water-based lubes, it helps to know some science.

Chapter 2:

Water Lube Science

You shouldn’t need a chemistry degree to pick out a lube.  However, by understanding pH, osmolality, and how they interact with your delicate tissue, you’ll be a much better judge of water-based lubes.

Osmolality Explained

In 2012, the United Nations’ World Health Organization announced that all water lubricants above an osmolality of 380 mOsm/kg are a potential health hazard and should be avoided [1].

Osmolality is the concentration of a solution, aka the amount of stuff in water besides H2O.  Using scientific instruments call osmometers, scientists can measure a liquid’s osmolality and get a number of mOsm/kg or milismoles per kilogram.

Here’s some osmolality measurements of different liquids [14]:

  • Pure water – 0 mOsm/kg
  • Tap Water – 3 mOsm/kg
  • Peppermint Tea – 184 mOsm/kg
  • Cell Fluid – 285 mOsm/kg
  • Blood – 290 mOsm/kg
  • Sperm – 380 mOsm/kg
  • Fanta – 415 mOsm/kg
  • Carrot Juice – 561 mOsm/kg
  • Red Wine – 2573 mOsm/kg

Cell fluid, at 280-290 mOsm/kg, is also the osmolality of the vaginal and anal environment.  Safe lubricants are Iso-osmolar to cell fluid, meaning they are close to this 280-290 range, and like the United Nations recommends, we definitely want to avoid lubes above 380 mOsm/kg, aka the hyperosmolar.


A hyperosmolar lube has a higher osmolality than the fluid in your cells, and when the two touch, osmosis happens, a reaction where natural forces attempt to balance the difference of water in two concentrations.  

This means lube will suck water out of your tissue causing cell death and tissue dehydration.  The long term affects of using hyperosmolar lubes include dryness, painful irritation, B.V., yeast infection risk, and lowered STI defenses [7-13].    

Some hyperosmolar lubes include K-Y Jelly, Astroglide Liquid, and Wild liquid [36].  The most hyperosmolar lube studied is K-Y warming jelly at 10,300 mOsm/kg, 36 times the bodies natural level.  A 2010 study showed that mice exposed to the KYWJ were 9 times more susceptible to herpes. [11]


These lubes have a lower osmolality than your tissue.  Now the tables are turned, and your cells suck the water out of lubricants, causing them to swell and eventually burst.

Hypo-osmolar lubes are more rare than hyper-osmolar lubricants, and there is only one study showing that a hypo-osmolar lubricant (Slippery Stuff) caused damage to vaginal tissue [6].  

Slippery stuff had an osmolality of 13, about 22 times less than the your natural lubricant’s osmolality.  Other lubes like Sliquid H2O have an osmolality of 103 (three times less), but didn’t cause any damage to vaginal tissue.


These lubes are closest to that sweet spot of 285-295 osmolality.  When an iso-osmolar lube and cell meet they respect each other’s personal space and don’t steal water from the other.  ‘Leave the vagina as you found it’ is the motto of iso-osmolar personal lubricants.

Iso-osmolar lubes are the safest and have been shown to not only leave the epithelial layer unscathed, but to also restore and rejuvenate cell growth [13].

Lube pH

The pH scale measures how acidic a liquid is. 0 pH is the most acidic, and 14 pH is the least acidic.

The vagina is naturally acidic, with a pH of 3.5 – 4.5 [15].  This acidity, created by lactic-acid producing lactobacilli, keeps the vagina clean, and prevents bad bacteria and pathogens from growing out of control [6][15][16].

A vaginal lube should have a pH in this 3.5 – 4.5 range.  If the pH is too high, the lube can lower your natural defenses against infections and STIs.

The anal environment is less acidic than the vagina, with a pH of 6-7 for the anal cavity.  The slight acidity acts as a buffer between alkaline fecal matter and the body.  Since most water-based lubes have a pH of 4-5, some people with sores or lesions can have burning when using these lubes anally.

If you experience any burning during anal play, try switching to a silicone-based or plant-based lube, which don’t have pH levels.

Chapter 3:

Vaginal and Anal Tissue

The vagina is very skilled at taking care of itself and keeping things clean.  Vaginal fluids flush out anything that shouldn’t be there, and healthy flora produce lactic acid to kill off attacking microbes. [15]

However, if the natural ecosystem is disrupted, the risks of infection increase.  To better understand how things get unbalanced, it helps to know a bit about the Epithelium, Mucosa, and Lactobacilli.

Epithelial Layer (Epithelium)

Both the vagina and the rectum have epithelium, the outer most layer of skin and first line of defense against pathogens and STIs.  The epithelium in the rectum is only one cell layer thick and very delicate.  Epithelium in the vagina is several cell layers deep, making it more flexible and durable. [17]

Epithelial layer cells are the first ones damaged by the hyperosmolar lubes we talked about in the previous section.  Damaged cells means the epithelium barrier is compromised and STIs can stroll right in [6][9][13].

Below are 4 images from a 2018 study comparing the effects of different lubricants on epithelium. Iso-osmolar lubricants like Aloe Cadabra had no effect on barrier integrity, while hyperosmolar lubes like K-Y and Astroglide caused significant tearing.

The effects of different lubricants on vaginal epithelium[13]

Mucous Membrane (Mucosa)

Mucous membranes are moist skin inside orifices like the nose, mouth, vagina and rectum.  The mucous they produce washes away foreign matter and adds lubrication for things coming in and out of the body.  The epithelial layer we just talked about is the first layer of the mucosa.

The vaginal mucosa absorbs chemicals very easily [15].

In fact, absorbtion is so effective that scientists have even been experimenting delivering drugs vaginally instead of orally [18].  This is another reason why it’s important to be careful of what you put inside your vagina.  No one knows the long term effects of absorbing risky ingredients like petrochemicals and xenoestrogens into the blood stream.

Lactobacilli – The Vagina’s Little Gatekeepers

The vagina has its own ecosystem of bacteria called Flora.  In a healthy individual, the prevalent species is Lactobacilli and the Lactic acid they produce lowers vaginal pH and prevents infections. Lactobacilli also attach themselves to the epithelial layer cells, preventing bad bacteria from having a place to set up shop [19].

If a lube with strong preservatives kills off the lactobacilli the gates to the vagina are left unguarded; pH increases and bad bacteria swoop in and take over, causing infections like B.V. and yeast infections [15].

K-Y Jelly kills all 3 species of Lactobacillus it’s applied to, which researchers believed was caused by the ingredient Chlorahexidine, a strong preservative. [6]  In the same study, silicone lubricants, plant-based lubricants, and water-based lubricants using citric acid as a preservative did not kill lactobacillus.


Chapter 4:

Lube Reactions

Unpleasant lube reactions either happen quickly, within a few minutes to a few hours after using them, or gradually, taking weeks of regular use to show up.

Sudden Lube Reactions

These happen after a few minutes of exposure and cause stinging, burning, and rashes.

Contact Dermatitis includes rashes, bumps, and redness, along with itchiness or pain. It’s been known to be caused by lube chemicals like N9, Glycerin, and Chlorahexidine.  The risk of having a reaction depends on how sensitive your skin is, and how much lubricant you use.

Allergic reactions are when your body has an auto-immune response to a chemical.  These are rare and risk varies from person to person.  Some ingredients that are more likely to cause an allergic reaction are chlorhexidine and benzocaine.

Gluten Intolerance –  If you suffer from celiacs disease, avoid ingesting lubes with oat beta gluten and vitamin E tocopherals, which can cause gluten intolerance symptoms.

Gradual Lube Reactions

These happen after using a lubricant regularly for weeks.  Over constant exporsure, a harsh lube disrupts the vagina’s natural environment leading to Bactera infections, yeast infections, and an increased chance of contracting STIs [13].

The worst part is that most people blame their body, diet, or their partner for infections and go right on using harmful lubricants.

Bacterial Vaginosis (BV)

If vaginal flora becomes unbalanced from Lactobacilli death, then harmful bacteria like Gardnerella Vaginalis and Mycoplasma multiply out of control and can reach 1000 times their normal level. [20]

The heightened bad bacteria count causes discolored discharge, a strong fishy smell, itching, burning after peeing, increased STI risk, and premature births.  Bacterial vaginosis has also been found to be associated with cervicitis, endometritis, salpingitis, and tubal factor infertility. [20]

B.V. can go away on its own, but in serious situations requires anti-biotics for treatment. [21]

Vaginal Yeast Overgrowth (Candidiasis)

Another member of vaginal flora is a yeast called Candida. It’s also kept in line by Lactobacilli, and it also grows out of control if Lactobacilli is missing.  Too much candida growth leads to Candidiasis, a yeast infection that shows up as a visible white fungus and feels itchy and uncomfortable [15].

Candida can also have a grow out of control from feeding on water-based lubes containing glycerin, or maltodextrin, and on flavored lubes with sugar or honey [7].

Increased STI Risk

Harsh Lubes increase the risk of STIs in more way than one.

First, when hyperosmolar lubes damage the epithelial layer, susceptibility to STIs like HIV and Herpes increases [6-13].

Second, Lactobacilli kill-off lowers vaginal acidity, a natural defense against pathogens. In addition, conditions caused by the lack of lactobacilli, like BV and Candidiasis, even further compromise defenses. [15]

Other studies have found that polymer Ingredients like PQ15 can aid the viral infection processes by increasing viral attachment [22-25]. PQ15 is an artificial preservative found in Astroglide Liquid.


Chapter 5:

Lube Regulations & Animal Testing

It’s been since 7 years since the United Nations’ WHO announced that hyperosmolar lubes have big risks.

So why are they still on the shelves in the USA?  It all comes down to the FDA approval process for personal lubricants, which some scientists aren’t very happy with. [13]

For starters, a new lube is tested on rabbits and not people.  Not only is it cruel to put K-Y warming jelly on a rabbit, but their vaginal environment is very different to a person’s [26].

Lube Researcher Richard Cone argues that this difference makes safety tests inaccurate.

A Rabbit Afraid of K-Y Warming Jelly

The FDA approval process tests new personal lubricants on rabbits.

Moreover, the FDA considers anal use an off-label application of personal lubricants and does not do any tests exposing them to tissue in the rectum [7].

Considering that 89% of MSM relationships use lubricant [1], and the damage of hyperosmolar lubes to colorectal tissue [13], a large group of at-risk people are ignored.

The FDA also has GRAS, a list of chemicals that are “Generally Recognized as Safe” and products containing GRAS ingredients do not need to be tested. Richard Cone argues that GRAS chemicals are tested on the skin, NOT vaginal tissue, which is a very different environment [13].

Once these not-so-safe lubes are approved, a company doesn’t have to list the ingredients on the label, which makes self-regulation difficult. [7]


Chapter 6:

Behind The Label: Lube Ingredients

Every lube ingredient falls into a category: some add thickness, some help disperse the ingredients evenly, and some are preservatives to prevent mold and bacteria from growing. 

Ingredient Purposes:

  • Base – makes up majority of a lube, other ingredients are added to the base to get the desired properties.
  • Preservatives – prevent mold and bacteria from growing and increases the lube shelf life.
  • Thickeners – keep the base from being too runny.
  • Dispersants – keep ingredients from separating.
  • Humectants – prevent a lubricant from evaporating.
  • Flavors – added to to oral lubricants for a better taste.

Chemical Categories

  • Petrochemicals – ingredients derived from crude oil.
  • Xenoestrogens – chemicals that mimic the effects of estrogen and can cause sexual development problems

What’s In Your Lube?

Glycerin thickens water and works as a humectant to prevent K-Y from evaporating.

  • A sugar alcohol that can be derived from soybeans, petroleum, animal fats and palm trees.
  • Glycerin greatly increases the osmolality of a lubricant[6], which can contribute to cell death, irritation, and yeast overgrowth. [6-13]

Found In: K-Y Jelly, Astroglide Liquid

Carrageenan – A natural thickener derived from red seaweed.

  • Can reduce and inhibit HIV, Herpes, and HPV transmission without causing damage to mucous membranes. [29]

Found In: Waterslide

Chlorhexidine is a synthesized chemical used as a disinfectant and anti-septic.

  • In lube, it is used as an inexpensive preservative.
  • Chlorhexidine was found to kill 3 types of Lactobacillus it was exposed to [6].  Lactobacilli creates lactic acid in the vagina, and helps prevents bacteria infections and STI transmission.

Found In: K-Y Jelly

Citric Acid – If your lubricant smells like lemons, it probably contains citric acid, the most common preservative used in organic water-based lubes.

  • Increases the acidity of a lubricant
  • Natural and mild preservative

Found In: Waterslide

Sodium Hydroxide is used in soap, detergents, and drain cleaning fluid.  Also known as caustic soda or lye.

  • Works as a preservative in personal lubricants
  • Caused epithelial cell damage when used at a concentration of 2.5% [28]

Found In: K-Y Jelly

Polyquaternium-15 – Polyquaternium, abbreviated PQ, is a family of synthesized chemicals that comes in 55 different numbers.  Each number is a a different variation of Polyquarternium, and shows the chronological order that it was registered with the International Nomenclature for Cosmetic Ingredients (INCI).  The newest at the time of this article’s writing is PQ-55.

  • Works as a preservative and makes lube more gel-like.
  • In tests it has been shown to increase the permeability of cell walls, and increase the risk of contracting HIV [12].
  • Causes inflammation to epithelial cells [27]
  • Can be absorbed into the body through open sores and damaged tissue.  Long term effects of repeated exposure are unknown.

Found In: Astroglide Liquid

Organic Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Juice is made from the aloe vera plant and also called aloe vera juice.  It’s mostly water, but contains minerals that strengthen, soothe, and repair tissues, instead of harming them.

  • Aloe Vera also has natural anti-fungal and anti-microbial properties [30] and requires less preservatives than water-based lubricants.

Found In: Good Clean Love

Methylparaben / Propylparaben – Parabens are synthetic preservatives and weak xenoestrogens.

  • Any chemical ending in -paraben belongs to the paraben family.  The strongest irritant is butylparaben, and others include methylparaben, propylparaben, and ethylparaben.
  • Weak xenoestrogens and shown to disrupt hormone dependent organs in gerbils [31], however no studies have determined potential effects of parabens applied directly to the genitals.

Found In: Astroglide Liquid

Potassium Sorbate – A potassium salt that occurs naturally in berries, but is usually created synthetically.  It works as a preservative and keeps mold and fungus from growing inside a lubricant.

  • Used in small amounts as a natural preservative in lube.
  • Lubes containing it were not shown to cause epithelial cell damage or Lactobacilli death [6]

Found In: Good Clean Love

Propylene Glycol – A substitute for glycerin that works as a humectant to prevent water from evaporating.

  • Can be made from petroleum or corn syrup.
  • Like glycerin, it greatly increases the osmolality of a lube [6] and puts you at risk for irritation, B.V., cell death, and increased vulnerability to STIs [6-13]

Found In: Astroglide Liquid

Sodium Benzoate – This is a preservative produced by reacting sodium hydroxide and benzoic acid.

  • It’s been shown cause contact dermatitis and epithelial damage when used in concentrations above 5% [32]
  • In lubes using less than 1% Sodium Benzoate, like Good Clean Love, was not shown to damage vaginal tissue or vaginal flora [6][13]

Found In: Good Clean Love

Propendiol (Natural)- Naturally derived propendiol is a clear viscous liquid and a natural humectant used to prevent water-based lubricants from evaporating.

  • Derived from corn syrup and makes up a small percentage of the lubricant.
  • In rare cases can cause irritation in people with sensitive skin.

Found In: Waterslide

Chapter 7:

Finding Your Perfect Lube

Since every body is different, there’s no guarantee that any one lube will work perfectly for everyone.

We can get pretty accurate, though, just by searching for lubes that meet our own personal criteria and needs.

Here are the ideal lubes to use for different types of sexual activity.


  • Water-based
  • Silicone-based
  • Plant-based

Best Safe Anal Lubes

Anal Lubricants should be…

  • Thick and long lasting; extra cushion for the pushing
  • Silicone-based (unless using silicone sex toys)
  • If water-based, anal lube should be iso-osmolar with a pH of 6-7

Here are some good anal lubes that meet the above requirements.

  • Sliquid Silver – silicone based
  • Uberlube – silicone based
  • Pjur Back Door – silicone based
  • Sliquid Sassy (Thickest Iso-Osmolar Water Lube)
  • Aloe Cadabra (Water)
  • Ride H20 (Water)
  • Southern Butter Bliss-on

Lubes For Conception

Lubes with glycerin can damage sperm cells and slow their journey to the uterus.  Here are some glycerin free lubes that will help, not hinder, the baby-making process.

  • Waterslide – good for sensitive skin or skin allergies, good if you are prone to chronic BV or yeast infections.
  • Coconu Water Based – Natural and organic
  • Yes Baby – Natural and organic
  • Preseed
  • Sliquid Organics Oceanics

Flavored Lubes

When it comes to flavored lubes it is important to avoid products that contain sugars and sugar derivatives, which can cause a yeast infection.

The flavored lubes in this list contain natural flavorings that don’t mask natural tastes – they just enhance them.  They contain small amounts of citric acid, which is a preservative found in foods and completely edible.

  • Hathor Lubricant Lickeurs – natural & organic
  • Sliquid swirl – 8 flavors
  • Aloe Cadabra Flavored Lubes
  • Blossom Organics

Warming and Stimulating Lubes

Warming and stimulating lubes contain different herbal extracts.  Some contain small amounts of Capsaicin which is also found in chilli peppers.

  • Power Glide – Best for penises
  • On Arousal Oil
  • Arousal Balm
  • Southern Butter Enhance Balm
  • Hathor Aphrodisia (Warming)
  • Aloe Cadabra Peppermint Tingle (Warming)
  • Blossom Organics Warm Sensation (Warming)



[1] World Health Organization. “Use and procurement of additional lubricants for male and female condoms”, 2012,

[2] Carballo-Diéguez A, Stein Z, Sáez H, Dolezal C, Nieves-Rosa L, Díaz F. “Frequent use of lubricants for anal sex among men who have sex with men: the HIV prevention potential of a microbicidal gel.” American Journal of Public Health, 2000, 90(7):1117-1121

[3]Herbenick, Debby, et al. “Women’s Use and Perceptions of Commercial Lubricants: Prevalence and Characteristics in a Nationally Representative Sample of American Adults.” The Journal of Sexual Medicine, vol. 11, no. 3, 2014, pp. 642–652., doi:10.1111/jsm.12427.

[4]Reece, Michael, et al. “Men’s Use and Perceptions of Commercial Lubricants: Prevalence and Characteristics in a Nationally Representative Sample of American Adults.” The Journal of Sexual Medicine, vol. 11, no. 5, 2014, pp. 1125–1135., doi:10.1111/jsm.12480.

[5]Maida, Jesse. “Personal Lubricant Market on an Upward Trend as Acceptance Increases: Technavio.” Personal Lubricant Market on an Upward Trend as Acceptance Increases: Technavio | Business Wire, 6 Dec. 2016,

[6]Dezzutti, Charlene S., et al. “Is Wetter Better? An Evaluation of Over-the-Counter Personal Lubricants for Safety and Anti-HIV-1 Acitivity.” PLoS ONE, Public Library of Science, 2012,

[7]Thomas, Pat. “Behind the label: K-Y Jelly” The Ecologist, Oct. 2007.

[8]Wolf, Lauren. “Studies Raise Questions About Safety Of Personal Lubricants.” Chemical & Engineering News, vol. 90, no. 50, 2012, pp. 45–46.

[9]Fuchs, Edward J., et al. “Hyperosmolar Sexual Lubricant Causes Epithelial Damage in the Distal Colon: Potential Implication for HIV Transmission.” The Journal of Infectious Diseases, vol. 195, no. 5, 2007, pp. 703–710., doi:10.1086/511279.

[10]Adriaens, Els, and Jean Paul Remon. “Mucosal Irritation Potential of Personal Lubricants Relates to Product Osmolality as Detected by the Slug Mucosal Irritation Assay.” Sexually Transmitted Diseases, vol. 35, no. 5, 2008, pp. 512–516., doi:10.1097/olq.0b013e3181644669.

[11]Moench, Thomas R, et al. “Microbicide Excipients Can Greatly Increase Susceptibility to Genital Herpes Transmission in the Mouse.” BMC Infectious Diseases, vol. 10, no. 1, 2010, doi:10.1186/1471-2334-10-331.

[12]Begay, Othell, et al. “Identification of Personal Lubricants That Can Cause Rectal Epithelial Cell Damage and Enhance HIV Type 1 Replication in Vitro.” AIDS Research and Human Retroviruses, vol. 27, no. 9, 2011, pp. 1019–1024., doi:10.1089/aid.2010.0252.

[13]Ayehunie, Seyoum, et al. “Hyperosmolal Vaginal Lubricants Markedly Reduce Epithelial Barrier Properties in a Three-Dimensional Vaginal Epithelium Model.” Toxicology Reports, vol. 5, 2018, pp. 134–140., doi:10.1016/j.toxrep.2017.12.011.

[14]Samuel Mettler, Department of Agricultural and Food Sciences, ETH Zurich, et al. “Osmolality and PH of Sport and Other Drinks Available in Switzerland.” Osmolality and PH of Sport and Other Drinks Available in Switzerland, 2006.

[15]Nicole, Wendee. “A Question for Women’s Health: Chemicals in Feminine Hygiene Products and Personal Lubricants.” Environmental Health Perspectives, vol. 122, no. 3, 2014, doi:10.1289/ehp.122-a70.

[16]Paternoster, D. M., et al. “Efficacy of an Acidic Vaginal Gel on Vaginal PH and Interleukin-6 Levels in Low-Risk Pregnant Women: a Double-Blind, Randomized Placebo-Controlled Trial.” The Journal of Maternal-Fetal & Neonatal Medicine, vol. 15, no. 3, 2004, pp. 198–201., doi:10.1080/14767050410001668310.

[17]Cone, R. A. “Vaginal Microbiota and Sexually Transmitted Infections That May Influence Transmission of Cell-Associated HIV.” Journal of Infectious Diseases, vol. 210, no. suppl 3, 2014, doi:10.1093/infdis/jiu459.

[18]Hussain, Alamdar, and Fakhrul Ahsan. “The Vagina as a Route for Systemic Drug Delivery.” Journal of Controlled Release, vol. 103, no. 2, 2005, pp. 301–313., doi:10.1016/j.jconrel.2004.11.034.

[19]Wira, Charles R., et al. “Epithelial Cells in the Female Reproductive Tract: a Central Role as Sentinels of Immune Protection.” American Journal of Reproductive Immunology, vol. 53, no. 2, 2005, pp. 65–76., doi:10.1111/j.1600-0897.2004.00248.x.

[20]Taylor, Brandie Depaoli, et al. “Does Bacterial Vaginosis Cause Pelvic Inflammatory Disease?” Sexually Transmitted Diseases, vol. 40, no. 2, 2013, pp. 117–122., doi:10.1097/olq.0b013e31827c5a5b.

[21]Ness, Roberta. “Can Known Risk Factors Explain Racial Differences in the Occurrence of Bacterial Vaginosis?” Journal of the National Medical Association, 2003.

[22]Le Doux JM. Landazuri N. Yarmush ML, et al. Complexation of retrovirus with cationic and anionic polymers increases the efficiency of gene transfer. Hum Gene Ther. 2001;12:1611–1621.

[23]Manning JS. Hackett AJ. Darby NB., Jr. Effect of polycations on sensitivity of BALD-3T3 cells to murine leukemia and sarcoma virus infectivity. Appl Microbiol. 1971;22:1162–1163.

[24]Pan LZ. Werner A. Levy JA. Detection of plasma viremia in human immunodeficiency virus-infected individuals at all clinical stages. J Clin Microbiol. 1993;31:283–288.

[25]Toyoshima K. Vogt PK. Enhancement and inhibition of avian sarcoma viruses by polycations and polyanions. Virology. 1969;38:414–426.

[26]Castle, Philip E., et al. “Contraceptive Testing of Vaginal Agents in Rabbits.” Contraception, vol. 58, no. 1, 1998, pp. 51–60., doi:10.1016/s0010-7824(98)00059-6.

[27]Paimela, Tuomas, et al “The preservative polyquaternium-1 increases cytoxicity and NF-kappaB linked inflammation in human corneal epithelial cells” Molecular Vision, 2012.

[28]Malvasio, Valeria, et al. “Effects of Sodium Hydroxide Exposure on Esophageal Epithelial Cells in an in Vitro Ovine Model: Implications for Esophagus Tissue Engineering.” Journal of Pediatric Surgery, vol. 47, no. 5, 2012, pp. 874–880., doi:10.1016/j.jpedsurg.2012.01.033.

[29]Coggins, C. “Preliminary Safety and Acceptability of a Carrageenan Gel for Possible Use as a Vaginal Microbicide.” Sexually Transmitted Infections, vol. 76, no. 6, 2000, pp. 480–483., doi:10.1136/sti.76.6.480.

[30]Antonisamy, Johnson Marimuthu Alias, et al. “Anti-Bacterial And Antifungal Activity Of Aloe Vera Gel Extract.” International Journal of Biomedical and Advance Research, vol. 3, no. 3, 2012, doi:10.7439/ijbar.v3i3.294.

[31]Costa, Janaína R., et al. “Endocrine-Disrupting Effects of Methylparaben on the Adult Gerbil Prostate.” Environmental Toxicology, vol. 32, no. 6, 2017, pp. 1801–1812., doi:10.1002/tox.22403.

[32]B, Nair. “Final Report on the Safety Assessment of Benzyl Alcohol, Benzoic Acid, and Sodium Benzoate.” International Journal of Toxicology, vol. 20, no. 3_suppl, 2001, pp. 23–50., doi:10.1080/10915810152630729.

Medically Reviewed by Sarah Melancon, Ph.D

sarah melancon headshot sexologist


I’m a Sociologist and Certified Sexologist (ACS) who takes a holistic approach to sexuality — I believe mind, body, heart, and spirit interact to create our sexual experiences, for better or for worse!  My work focuses on the influence of attachment and trauma (big and small) on sexuality and relationships and embodied, somatic approaches to healing sexual difficulties.  I’m a lifelong nerd who is always learning, but more importantly, I’m a human being who just wanted to enjoy her sex life.  When I took my first sexuality course in 2005, I realized there could (possibly maybe hopefully) be answers to the problems that privately plagued me, and soon began focusing on sexuality and sexual health in graduate school.

At age 4, I was diagnosed with severe social phobia and a communication disorder called selective mutism; I easily became overwhelmed and frozen around people, often unable to speak — ‘awkward’ should have been my middle name.  Fast forward to adulthood, and no wonder sexuality and relationships were equally fascinating and confusing!  But despite getting a Ph.D., reading all the books; listening to all the podcasts; working with therapists, coaches, and healers; running a YouTube channel with millions of views and a podcast downloaded by tens of thousands each month; speaking at sexuality conferences, and even asking my fellow colleagues for advice — I was still left without a complete answer or an effective way out.  There was no obvious “diagnosis” for my experience, and as selective mutism took over my life once again, my life and career began to fall apart.

I was first introduced to the “answer” in 2015 through a podcast interview with Stephen Porges, on his Polyvagal Theory about the autonomic nervous system.  Only a few months prior, a therapist was amazed to point out, “You just cycled from fight to flight to freeze within only 90 seconds” and my reaction was, “Huh?”  While I only understood about 10% of what Porges said, deep down I knew Polyvagal Theory somehow explained both my social and sexual issues.  Life has a funny way of (eventually) leading us to the right path, however, and developing PTSD after a traumatic childbirth ironically shined a light on my world of growing darkness.  Diving into the world of trauma, neurobiology, and somatic healing approaches, I not only came to understand Polyvagal Theory and how I developed PTSD (and published a book chapter on both) but FINALLY, my social phobia, selective mutism, and sexual problems made sense!

My painful journey showed me that while our sexual desires can be a path to greater intimacy and connection, they also reveal our deepest fears, hopes, dreams, and traumas that we keep hidden in the shadows, unconsciously re-creating the same emotional wounds that keep us disconnected and stuck.  By cultivating embodied awareness, learning self-compassion, and healing the underlying traumas endemic to modern society, our most hidden corners of shame can become our greatest sources of power.  I’ve come to believe that human beings are wired for relationships, and that embracing the awkward by connecting with greater love, authenticity, and intimacy is one of the life’s most profound and meaningful experiences.


My approach is based on the work of Stephen Porges, Peter Levine, Bessel Van Der Kolk, Dan Siegel, Deb Dana, Pat Ogden, David Treleaven, Stanley Rosenberg, Stephen Karpman and dozens of others in the field of trauma, neurobiology, and somatic therapies.

In the field of sexuality and relationships, my influences include Diane Poole Heller, Stan Tatkin, Barry Komisurak, Cindy Meston, Lori Brotto, Beverly Whipple, John Bankroft, Sheri Winston, Emily Nagosaki, Francois de Carufel, and John and Julie Gottman, combined with decades of research on the autonomic nervous system, trauma, attachment, and sexual function.  Notably, these lists are incomplete, as I’m always learning!

I take a holistic, somatic approach in my current work with men recovering from erectile dysfunction and premature ejaculation.  I am honored to witness my clients’ vulnerability, self-discovery, and courage, whether at age 18 or 85.  Having been in their shoes, I am grateful to bring a sense of acceptance, understanding, and healing to my clients’ lives, and frequently hear, “You’re so easy to talk to!”  While I am not (yet) trained in Somatic Experiencing (SE), I have completed Irene Lyon’s Smart Body Smart Mind program based largely on the SE approach, completed SE-based workshops with Diane Poole Heller and David Treleaven, and am currently co-authoring a study using SE for eating disorder patients in recovery.  In addition, I co-created 5 research-backed trauma scales along with SE practitioner Ilene Smith, published in her book, Moving Beyond Trauma.

While my current focus is on men, I have a wealth of knowledge on women’s sexuality and in the future, intend to work with women and couples as well.


I don’t actually believe experts exist, because there’s always more to learn.  However, I’m grateful to have shared my knowledge and been quoted as one in dozens of outlets, including Cosmopolitan, Shape, Bustle, Men’s Health, AskMen, Good Housekeeping, High Times, Instyle, Lifehacker, Psych Central, Community Psychiatry, Healthline,,, Livestrong, MindBodyGreen, Tinder Swipelife, o.School, Kinkly, and Giddy.

Check out some of my favorite articles:

  • Jman Ceca says:


    Can you say anything about how safe powder J-Lube is in rectum/colon? Does it block pores or damage the colon?

    One other thing, some thick water based lubes when inserted in rectum in large quantities (50-100ml+) will actually cause a strong uncontrollable urge to expel it, yet other waterbased do not. What could cause this & is it dangerous?


    • Ian says:

      Hi Jman, J-lube contains PEG-90M, which can contain some nasty impurities such as ethylene oxide (a known carcinogen and suspected neurotoxin) and 1,4-dioxane (an irritant and suspected carcinogen). lists it as a chemical with a moderate to high hazard rating depending on usage. It may cause damage to the colon lining if used regularly over a long period. The good news is the colon also heals if you stop using it.

      If your water-based lube is hyper-osmolar it could suck up water from your lower intestine and rectum, similar to how an anally inserted laxative works. Your best choice is something like Sliquid Sassy which is thick but designed to have the same osmolality as the body. You can also try silicone based lubes which are inert and the safest lube to use. The only downside of silicone lube is that it can warp silicone dildos and toys.

    • Mike says:

      Hi ..Do not use J-Lube anally. I was using it and didnt realize I was getting sick from it. I ended up in the hospital with them running multiple tests to try and find out what was causing my illness.(didnt realize at the time that being sick had any relation to the use of the j-lube) all my lymph nodes were becoming enlarged and I was sent to an Oncologist because my Dr. said my bloodwork and other symptoms looked like signs of cancer. So after more testing and multiple CT scan the cause was still a mystery. As fate would have it during the period of being sick I had not been using any J-lube or having any sex for that matter . And over the coarse of several months symptoms went way completely and was feeling great. In that time I started enjoying sex and strted using J-Lube once again not knowing it was the cause of my sickness before and in a matter of a month or so all the same symptoms returned and was again very Ill. Im a slow learning but I figured out the cause (J-Lube which by the way does have a warning on it about adverse affects to the body having to do with the peritoneum)anyway I did a little research and now use Xantham Gum which works great,is very inexpensive , and as far as I know non toxic. The only down side Im aware of is that it has to be used right away and cant be store as there are no preservatives. If anyone has more info about Xanthum Gum Id love the input Thanks. P.S. been using it as a lube for over 2yrs thus far no negative issues

  • Khayrie says:

    This is a very informative article about different kinds of lubes and which ones are not good to use. I do hope lots of people especially those who uses lubes a lot to be able to read this and be aware as well as to inform friends as well.

  • Sandy says:

    This has been so very helpful for me. I suffer from BV. I end up taking at least 12 courses of antibiotics a year. So I’m now going to try some different lube and fingers crossed it helps. But if anyone has any tips on how to prevent BV or at least slow it all down plz send me a email.?

    • George says:

      Application of Cold-Pressed (Virgin) Coconut Oil has been known as beneficial to cure bacterial vaginosis. If I were you, I’d at least try it.
      And please avoid antibiotics. They are made to cure symptoms and not rhe root cause.
      I’d like to invite you to my page about lubes and sexual topics
      Best regards.

  • Jenna says:

    Hello! May I make a suggestion? People CAN be allergic to silicone, even medical grade silicone as I am, though it is rare. So people who try out silicone lube and then, like me, develop horrible symptoms from it can be made aware that it might be the silicone. I developed it immediately after trying silicone lube the first time for less than a minute and now even medical grade, pure silicone has an immediate reaction anywhere on my body. Thank you! Great info! 🙂

  • Sounder says:

    This is a great page! The most thorough discussion I’ve seen of sex lubricants short of scientific articles and journals.

    However, I have one criticism: except for 1 short and inconclusive paragraph I found nothing on lubricants for urethral sounding. I’ve been looking for an alternative to Surgilube, which was recommended by a local sex toy shop and seems to be Amazon’s recommendation as well. Problem is the stuff gives me a burning sensation within a few minutes of use, and I’m not a masochist so that’s not a good thing.

    So I’m planning to risk $5 and try some pure coconut oil instead. I’ve chatted with some men online who swear by the stuff for masturbation, but not necessarily for use inside the urethra. Do you think this is a good choice? Do you have any other recommendations?


    • JC Ways says:

      If you’re doing sounding, you need a surgical lubricant of the highest quality. You might find one at a medical supply store or on Amazon, just make sure that it’s well-rated!

  • Just Dave says:

    For male masturbation, you cannot beat canola oil. The skin does not absorb it, so if you stretch your session out for an hour or longer, it will be just as good as when you began. A very little canola oil will lube up the largest dick, so apply it sparingly. Keep a couple of paper towels handy to clean up after you cum.

    Canola oil is also odorless and tasteless. If you’re jerking off with a friend or two and things turn oral, there will be no unpleasantness. It’s a food product.

    Canola oil is readily available in any supermarket and it’s reasonably priced. And because it’s a common household item, there’s no need to keep it under wraps.

    • JC Ways says:

      Hey Dave, sounds like I’ll have to try it! Oil-based lubes are great for masturbation – I’m persoanlly a big fan of coconut oil 🙂

  • Frank says:

    Hi Sarah, thank you for this valuable information. Quick question. Can any of these lubricants be used in such a way that vaginal sex if followed by oral sex, with a re-application in between? And therefore making the man taste great after the main job is done?

    • JC Ways says:

      Hi Frank, generally speaking, flavored lubricants are best reserved for oral sex exclusively and shouldn’t be used for vaginal/anal sex because the flavorings can irritate the vaginal/anal tissues.

      You would be best reapplying flavored lube for oral sex if you’ve just used regular lube for vaginal sex.

      Unless we’re misunderstanding your question?

  • Dean says:

    Thank you for interesting article, but I have one question: Where I live only those lubes are available in drug stores: Durex gels, One Touch gels and Masculan gels. Me and my partner both like vaginal and anal sex and I don’t know which from those gels could be better for us. Could you give us advice? Thanks in advance.

    • JC Ways says:

      Silicone-based lubes last the longest. Gun Oil is particualrly good for anal sex!

      • Dean says:

        Yes, I read that too that silicons are best for that, but unfortunately only lubes I can see here are Durex, One Touch, Masculan and Sico. Are these gels any good? And especially for anal sex?

        • JC Ways says:

          Durex is a fairly reputable brand, but I’d recommend ordering something like Gun Oil Silicone-Based Lube on Amazon 🙂

  • Recent Blog Posts

    10 Best FTM Sex Toys for Trans Men in 2024

    Finding the right FMT sex toys may feel like a mission impossible for trans men and transmasculine people. We’re not…

    7 Top VR Sex Cams and Porn Sites to Enjoy Your Most Intimate Moments

    Had enough of the same old routine on regular cam and porn sites? It might be time to try something…

    Best Latina Cams: Find The Hottest Latina Cam Girls (2024)

    Have you ever wondered what it is about Latina girls that brings that extra spark to cam shows? Maybe it’s…

    Vibrations & More

    10 Best FTM Sex Toys for Trans Men in 2024

    Finding the right FMT sex toys may feel like a mission impossible for trans men and transmasculine people. We’re not…

    13 Best Interactive Sex Toys in 2024

    I’ll just go out and say it – interactive sex toys are the best thing that has happened to the…

    25 Best Clit Vibrators For Women: Guide To Mini, Wand, and Sucking Clit Vibes

    37% of women need clitoral stimulation in order to orgasm. In fact, 64% of women use both clitoral and vaginal…

    5 Vibrating Panties to Rock Your World In Public [2024]

    Do you crave the thrill of a dangerous yet pleasurable public orgasm? If so, vibrating panties might be your new favorite…

    5 Best Vibrating Butt Plugs for Anal Play [2024]

    You’ve heard of butt plugs. You’ve heard of vibrators. Now allow me to introduce vibrating butt plugs! Suitable for any…