Butt Plug Sextravaganza: 31 Best Butt Plugs and Anal Toys

Butt plugs are a great way to warm up to anal sex, have intense anal orgasms, or ornament your ass with some sexy flair.

If you're new to butt plugs, the initiation is quite a difficult one and it is very important to know a few things before plowing ahead with it. The best way to recognize an anal toy or butt plug is by its flared base, which pretty much all anal toys will come with, but we’ll get into that later on.

In this article, we’re going to talk about why people use butt plugs, how you should use them, and some of the most important things you should know about these cute little (or big) toys.

The Best Butt Plugs

First we've put together a huge list of our top rated anal plugs where you can vote for your favorites, helping you to choose the best butt plug for you as you forge this path of glorious bum fun.

Most Colorful Butt Plug- Pride Plug

Pride butt plug LGBT is a beautiful toy, wonderfullycolored and with the flared base in shape of a heart. 3.2 inches long and 100% waterproof silicone, this fabulous butt plug is a great way for gay men to support LGBT pride while preparing their bottom for a wild ride.

PROS: 

  • Low price
  • Great 3.2-inch length – not too big or small
  •  Fabulous cause and design

CONS: 

  • Can only be used with water-based lube

Best Metal Butt Plug

Njoy Pure Plug Medium is one of those butt plugs that stay in no matter what. It is made of stainless steel so you can boil the toy in order to sanitize it, it has a ring flared base, and it is pretty good for beginners because it is not too large. It’s also an incredibly sleek and sexy design; it has that sort of “manly” sex toy look about it. It’s like something that a kinky CEO would keep in his drawer. Christian Grey probably has one.

PROS: 

  • The stainless steel is easy to clean
  • Sleek and sexy design
  • Ring flared base for easy use

CONS: 

  • Quite heavy
  • It is quite expensive

Best Stone Butt Plug - Laid B.1

Laid B.1 Stone Plug is a butt plug made out of stone. Yes, that’s right. It’s made out of stone. Perhaps this is how our ancestors got up to shenanigans in their caves? This stone plug is heavy (as you’d imagine) but it is quite small in size, so it could be good for beginners who are looking for something which will stay in easily. Maybe it’d be good for Flintstones roleplay.

PROS: 

  • The strong material will intensify the orgasm
  • It is easy to clean

CONS: 

  • It can be a heavy plug, especially for beginners
  • This plug is expensive, especially for a starter size

The Hole Bunch

The hole bunch is a set of anal toys in the shape of vegetables. I mean, who doesn’t want carrots and turnips up their ass? These silicone-based toys are great for all-day wear, and they are admittedly a little bit cute to look at.They’re on the pricey side, but you do get the whole set of 3 for the price, giving you multiple options for kinky and unique anal fun. It also has a pun name, and I have a guilty pleasure for those pun names.

PROS: 

  • The set is cheap as you get the three of them at that price
  • They are not too heavy
  • The set is ideal for role play
  • Perfect for beginners

CONS: 

  • No silicone lubricants can be used with them

'Fluke' Dual-Purpose Silicone Butt Plug

The hole punchCJ Hooker silicone dildo in green is a small handmade dildo that is a little bit expensive for a silicone toy. On the other hand, it is a butt plug that will stay in so this is one of the best butt plugs to wear all day. The insertable length is somewhere around 13 cm(5.25”), so this is a big one if you’re using it as a butt plug.

PROS: 

  • It is great for more advanced butt plug fans
  • Could also be used as a regular anal dildo

CONS: 

  • Little bit too expensive for a silicone toy

Piky, the Pikachu Tail Butt Plug

In case you didn’t grow up in the ‘90s like me, Piky is based on the tail of Pikachu, the Pokémon character, although I imagine they can’t officially say that for legal reasons. Thisoff-the-wall tail butt plug is 100% body-safe silicone and it is obviously ideal for geeky couples and people who are into anime role play. Ever secretly fancied doing an Ash and Pikachu roleplay? Well, now you can! I don’t judge. Maybe Psyduck can pop along too.

PROS: 

  • Nostalgia and sexiness align!
  • Ideal for people with role play as a fetish

CONS: 

  • It has a long tail which means the toy cannot be attached to a harness
  • The material is silicone, so only water-based lubricants are recommended

Tristan 1 silicone butt plug by vixen - purple

Tristan 1 silicone butt plug by vixen - purple is a plug that can be easily worn all day long. It is not a heavy toy and it is not too big. It’s great as an anal training plug and it can be your sleep partner if you are the type of person who enjoys sleeping with butt plugs in.

PROS: 

  • The flared base of this plug fits perfectly between your butt cheeks
  • It is a short and easy plug which can be kept in for a long time

CONS: 

  • Only water-based lubricants should be used

Octopus anal toy

You would think that they’d go with tentacles, but this Octopus anal toy is a butt plug with an octopus head as the insertable part of the plug. It’s a cute anal toy and this can be the best starter butt plug. It comes in two sizes, small and large (they’ve kept it nice and simple there). It is not heavy and some may consider this to be the best anal plug for men. It is made of body-safe silicone too, which is always a plus.

PROS: 

  • It’s a cute anal plug with a flared base that makes it attachable to a harness
  • It has two sizes, so it can be used by people with different experience levels
  • You can wear this plug for hours on end

CONS: 

  • Bit pricey
  • Not the sexiest of aesthetics really

Best Budget Butt Plug - Hole punch

Hole punch silicone butt plug - orange is a toy that comes in the shape of a bullet with a flared Bingo rainbow is an ingenious toy that is a bit like a cross between a butt plug and some anal beads which get progressively bigger as you go down. This hybrid shape is a great way to intensify orgasms, and the pastel rainbow colors make the toy even more fun and funky to use. This is a brilliant and unique anal toy for beginners and advanced anal players alike.base. You can insert it easy with plenty of lubricant and it is ideal for people who are new to anal stimulation with plugs. The orange color is also neat and unique in the sex toy world.

PROS: 

  • Cheap toy
  • Ideal for beginners
  • It will stay put once inserted

CONS: 

  • A bit basic

Bingo rainbow

Bingo rainbow is an ingenious toy that is a bit like a cross between a butt plug and some anal beads which get progressively bigger as you go down. This hybrid shape is a great way to intensify orgasms, and the pastel rainbow colors make the toy even more fun and funky to use. This is a brilliant and unique anal toy for beginners and advanced anal players alike.

PROS: 

  • Its shape can intensify orgasm
  • Fun and vibrant rainbow design

CONS: 

  • It can be quite expensive
  • Shape is not typical of a butt plug – could require practice

Fragaria

Fragaria is a luxurious toy made for people with a bit of spare cash. This gorgeous butt plug is made of brass and is silver plated, shaped into a sleek and sexy strawberry. The price is a bit on the high side, but if you can afford this, it’s definitely a great kinky gift, especially for a lady. Cream, anyone? It’s like a sexy Wimbledon up in here.

You can also pair it up with VR goggles via Bluetooth and watch specially-made videos online. The Launch syncs up with the content and simulates the on-screen movements. If you’ve ever been curious about virtual reality porn, this is your chance to try it!

PROS: 

  • Luxurious sweet piece
  • Can be used by beginners

CONS: 

  • Not easy to clean
  • The price is really steep

Magnetic white bunny tail plug

Want to feel like a cute little horny sex bunny that’s ready to get fucked? This magnetic white bunny tale is an anal plug made of Pyrex glass with rabbit-style fur at the bottom. The tail can easily be removed so if you don’t feel like wearing a bunny tail, you can just use it as a transparent butt plug instead.

PROS: 

  • It is a wonderful piece for people who like roleplay
  • The tail is detachable

CONS: 

  • Material is delicate
  • Pricey

Ass cram cone

Ass cram cone is a sweet toy inspired by Neapolitan ice cream. While I get that the name is a pun, I personally find the idea of “cramming it in your ass” a bit unappealing! Maybe they should’ve gone with a sexier name? Still, once it’s in, this anal plug will stay in. We recommend it for people with some experience in anal play due to its wide-ish shape.

PROS: 

  • It is an interesting ice-cream shaped toy
  • It will stay put, once inserted

CONS: 

  • It is quite expensive
  • Beginners can find it difficult to use
  • No silicone lubricants recommended

Etna anal stimulator

The Etna anal stimulator is a luxurious anal plug with Mount Etna as its flared base. This is another toy for people that can afford expensive toys! This one is made of brass with 24ct gold too,so don’t expect it to be too cheap if you’re looking to gift some sex toys on a budget.

PROS: 

  • Great high-class sexy present
  • Its shape is ideal for all levels of experience

CONS: 

  • Expensive
  • It can be hard to clean

Coco de Mer Ceramic Plug

This ceramic butt plug looks a bit like it belongs in your grandma’s cupboard. Make of that what you will! The product is also quite expensive. People with any kind of experience can use it as long as they are careful with the material, as ceramic has the potential to break if mishandled.

PROS: 

  • It has a very pretty look.

CONS: 

  • The ceramic material is delicate.

Rose bud glass butt plug

Rose bud glass is a unique and ornate bedazzled butt plug which features different widths down the shaft of the toy, making it great for more advanced users who like a challenge. In fact, the unusual shape on this “Rose Bud” butt plug can help you to orgasm much more intensely. Maybe that’s what Charles Foster Kane was trying to tell us before he died? Little reference for the film fans there.

PROS: 

  • The shape is made for intensifying the orgasm
  • Pretty and unique design

CONS: 

  • The material is delicate
  • Best for advanced users

Mini root

Mini root is a small and cute anal toy with an interesting surface somewhat reminiscent of “Groot” from Guardians of the Galaxy! It is made of 100% body-safe silicone and it has 3.5 inches that can be inserted. You can wear it easily under clothes as much as you want to, allowing you to go about your day with a kinky little plug in your ass. No one will ever know!

PROS: 

  • Interesting and realistic surface
  • Intensifies anal orgasm and G-spot stimulation

CONS: 

  • Silicone lubricants are not allowed
  • Hard to clean

Batt plug

Ever wanted to signal that you need a fucking from Batman and/or robin? We’ll now the Batt plug allows you to shine the bat signal straight out of your bottom! This sex toy is made of body-safe silicone with an insertable length of 3.5 inches. This toy can serve as a great anal plug for beginners, and the opportunities for DC roleplayand “bat” jokes are endless. Quick! Grab the BatLube!

PROS: 

  • Great for comic book roleplay
  • Both beginners and experienced people can use it

CONS: 

  • Must use water-based lube

The broad city ass of an angel silicone butt plug

The broad city ass of an angel silicone butt plug (catchy name) is another buttplug-dildo hybrid which can be used for a range of sexy purposes. It has 5 inches to be inserted and it’s made of silicone. This means that it can either be used as a modestly-sized dildo or a pretty large butt plug, depending on your preference. Take your pick, but this isn’t for the faint of heart!

PROS: 

  • Men and women can equally use it
  • Good price
  • Versatile – can be used as dildo or butt plug

CONS: 

  • May be too much for beginners

Avant soft silicone butt plug

Avant pride p6 beyond silicone butt plug is a sweet silicone toy ideal for singles or couples. It is long enough to make you feel pleasure even if you have some experience with anal plugs, and it has a nice flared base that will look gorgeous between your butt cheeks, giving your partner plenty to look at. You can easily wear this toy as long as you feel comfortable.

PROS: 

  • Comfortable flared base that will make the toy stay inside for hours
  • Ideal for starters and experienced people as well

CONS: 

  • No silicone lubricants allowed

Two in one butt plug

Hole Punch Butnik Silicone Butt Plug it is an interesting anal toy with a cock ring in the middle. This is an ideal toy for a couple or if you want to surprise your sex partner with such an interesting novelty. It has something for both of you – there is cock and anal stimulation to be had with this toy… what could be better?

PROS: 

  • Comes with a cock ring
  • Wonderful for G-spot and prostate stimulation

CONS: 

  • Not the sexiest-looking toy in the world

Funkit toy

This Funkit toy looks like it belongs in a contemporary art gallery more than a sex shop! This handmade silicone butt plug with a flared base can be attached to a harness, making it both pretty and versatile in the bedroom too. The Funkit can be used by both men and women; it has the potential to stimulate both the clitoris and the prostate if used properly.

PROS: 

  • Great for men and women
  • Affordable and cool-looking
  • It can be attached to a harness

CONS: 

  • Water-based lubes only

Fun Factory B Ball

Fun Factory B Ball is one of the best rated anal sex toys for beginners, as it comes with an insertable length of just 3 inches. However, this unique and naughty little toy comes with a ball inside its insertable section which rattles around inside the toy as you move, stimulating your ass. This would be especially good for prostate stimulation with guys! The small length even means you could wear it all day, getting exciting sensations from the ball rattling about as you drive your car, walk down the street, or send some mundane emails. Spice up your life!

PROS: 

  • Rattling ball for increased pleasure with movement
  • Flared base makes the toy fit wonderfully between your butt cheeks

CONS: 

  • Ball-rattling only works if having certain types of intercourse

Buddy silicone Butt Plug

Buddy silicone is a top butt plug that can be used for both female and male stimulation. You see, it’s shape is ideal for both male prostate stimulation and female vaginal stimulation, making it a great unisex anal sex toy. The butt plug is quite long and features a unique shape, so it’s definitely best left to people who have walked the anal walk a few times in their lives before.

PROS: 

  • Advanced P-spot and G-spot stimulation for men and women
  • Has the potential to create strong orgasms

CONS: 

  • Not very appealing aesthetics

​​​​Randy the Raccoon

Do you wanna roam around in the trash while looking for a fucking? Randy the Raccoon is a sweet tail plug that will be your best companion in animal-based role play. The material is stainless steel so you can boil it and clean it very easily. It is not too heavy and definitely not a giant toy, so this butt plug can easily be one of the best wearable butt plugs for people with some fun and frisky fetishes.

PROS: 

  • Racoon tail for role play
  • Modest size
  • Stainless steel – easy to boil and clean

CONS: 

  • A little heavy

Fun Factory Bootie

Fun Factory Bootie is one of the best rated toys out there. Made of silicone, this anal plug has an interesting base designed for extended wear. It’s a large toy, so this one is perfect if you have some experience in anal stimulation. It can be easily used for stimulating the prostate as well. It’s pretty plain and simple but it gets the job done.

PROS: 

  • Wear it under clothes easily
  • Perfect size for beginners and advanced users

CONS: 

  • A bit plain and simple

The Mighty Moaning Anal Rangers

Continuing with our previous theme of ‘90s kids TV show nostalgia, allow me to introduce the Mighty Moaning Anal Rangers! This series of anal plugs comes in large and small sizes so you don’t have to worry if you are a beginner. You can choose from different colors the one that suits you the best. Did you always like the yellow ranger the best? No problem. Have the hots for the pink ranger? Oh boy!

PROS: 

  • ‘90s Power Rangers nostalgia
  • The surface will intensify the feeling of orgasm
  • Easy and cheap (no that’s not an insult)

CONS: 

  • Unusual shape – hard to clean

Beginner Silicone Butt Plug

Anal training and sex toys can be really embarrassing and taboo topics for some people, especially if they live with their friends/family and they’re worried about getting a suspiciously long cardboard box in the mail. However, Beginner Silicone Phthalate Discreet Packaging is an anal training kit that you can find on Amazon with three different sizes: small, medium, and large, allowing you to work your way up the anal ladder over time. This discreetly-packaged kit has plenty of Amazon 5 star reviews, so you can rest assured that you’re in safe and low-key hands.

PROS: 

  • It has plenty of reviews so you can make your decision based on other people’s experiences
  • It has different sizes – you can gently work your way up
  • Discreet and low-key packaging

CONS: 

  • It is highly recommended not to use silicone lubricants

Paloqueth silicone anal plug toy kit

Paloqueth silicone anal plug toy kit is a set of anal toys that has plenty reviews on Amazon. This set is great for both women and men, intensifying orgasms for both. Some male reviewers even claim that they have cum hands-free from using these toys, although I imagine that’s quite difficult to achieve for most of us. It is a sweet training kit for anal stimulation like no other.

PROS: 

  • Very comfortable plugs that can stay comfortably inside you for hours
  • Made for both vaginal and anal orgasms

CONS: 

  • Can’t be used with silicone-based lube

Jewelry Anal Plug Stretching Kit

AKStore 3 Pcs Luxury Jewelry Design Fetish Stainless Steel is another interesting set with a very good price. It is made of stainless steel so it is easy to clean these toys by boiling them in water. There are loads of good reviews praising these butt plugs for their reliability, gradual size increase, and sleek look. When I’m putting something up my bum, I like to think that it’s reliable and pretty-looking.

PROS: 

  • Plenty of reviews
  • Easy to clean material
  • A great fit for any genre or experience

CONS: 

  • The material can be a little heavy, especially if you want to use it for hours

AKStore Small Super Steel Butt Plug

Looking for a cheeky little butt plug that’s easy to clean and maintain? The AKStore Small Super Steel Fetish Plug is a small steel butt plug which is great for yourself or as a gift for a partner. Due to the steel construction, you can be confident that the product won’t break while inside you (unless you do some insane sphincter exercises in the gym) and the product’s weightiness means that you won’t forget it’s there!

PROS: 

  • Stainless steel construction – easy to clean
  • Relatively short – great for beginners
  • The material is very strong and will not break inside you

CONS: 

  • The material can be a little too heavy

Bestimulus Wild Silicone Fox’s Tail

Do you like getting on all fours and prancing about like a naughty fox? Bestimulus Wild Silicone Fox’s Tail is a plug made for people who love this kind of furry role play. If you’re the kind of person who likes to frequent sex clubs, it can also be used as a kinky fashion accessory in addition to a nice jockstrap, for example. Attract your ass the attention it deserves.

PROS: 

  • Brilliant butt plug for foxy (get it?) role play
  • Can be used to attract attention!

CONS: 

  • Not the authentic colors of a fox tail

Cheap Rabbit Bunny Tail Anal Plug

Beauty7 Rabbit Bunny Tail is an interesting kit of anal toys that is wonderful for beginners as well as for the experienced ones too. The stainless steel plugs can be easily cleaned and used with any type of lubricant. The set comes with three toys of different sizes so don’t worry if you have limited experience in anal stimulation. This kit is for everyone.

PROS: 

  • The kit has bulb sizes to suit everyone
  • The bunny tail is great for cutesy roleplay

CONS: 

  • Not the best material

Minx Detachable Faux Pony Tail Plug

Baby Pink Crystal Minx Detachable Faux Pony Tail Plug is an interesting toy with a detachable pink pony tail. It’s a very campy/girly kind of toy, so it’s great for women and gay bottoms who are into unicorns and rainbows and all that good stuff. Do bear in mind that you need to be careful with the material, as it could easily become dirty and the tail could get yanked if you’re not careful.

PROS: 

  • Great for pony roleplay
  • Stays in for a long time

CONS: 

  • The material is delicate
  • Tail can get “tugged on” or stuck if not careful

Grey Wolf Crystal Tail Plug

Grey Wolf Crystal Minx Faux Fur Tail Plug is another toy made of glass. It’s perhaps one of the more “macho” butt plug tails on this list, most closely resembling a wolf’s tail. It can have a small, medium or a large bulb, which makes it really unique and versatile, allowing you to have a tail while using a butt plug size which suits you.

PROS: 

  • The wolf tail can boost your imagination in role play
  • It is easy so you can wear it for hours
  • Different sizes – versatile for different users

CONS: 

  • The material is very delicate
  • Quite an expensive plug

Crystal Delights Mini-Twist Plug

Who doesn’t want the Northern Lights shining bright up their ass? It’s a natural wonder! This Aurora Borealis Crystal Mini-Twist Plug is an interestingly-shaped toy which comes with a flared base that can be useful if you want to attach it to a harness. It comes in 2 different sizes, so don’t worry if you’re new to ass play – you can always get this opulent plug in a smaller size.

PROS: 

  • Opulent aurora borealis design
  • 2 different sizes

CONS: 

  • It is made out of a pretty delicate material

"Colors Against Cancer" Anal Plug

Black ColorsAgainst Cancer Plug is a very sleek and sophisticated anal toy that can serve as a wonderful sexual stimulator for girls and boys alike. When you buy one of these toys, a portion of your money will go toward various different cancer charities. Now that’s what I call corporate social responsibility! Who doesn’t want to get off and give money to a good cause?

PROS: 

  • A portion of the proceeds goes to cancer charities
  • The toy is easy to wear and will stay with you long enough to satisfy your kinky pleasures
  • It has an interesting black color, ideal for men and women alike

CONS: 

  • The glass can be delicate

Pineapple Delight Plug

Pineapple Delight Plug is a sweet princess toy with a Glacier Blue Swarovski crystal inside. This is a beautiful plug in the shape of pineapple (kind of), leading to some bumpy and interesting sensations inside your bottom. This handmade butt plug is a very opulent and elegant design; it almost looks like something that should be displayed on a purple cushion in the Tower of London. I wonder if the Queen and Phillip have one?

PROS: 

  • Very ornate and fancy-looking
  • Orgasm-intensifying shape
  • Ideal for both men and women

CONS: 

  • Delicate glass construction

Kink Signature 3” Silicone Butt Plug

Kink Signature 3” Silicone Butt Plug is a toy designed for both men and women with any level of experience. The toy has 2.5” to insert and can easily stimulate the prostate or the G-spot. It also has a “Kink signature” on its flared base.

PROS: 

  • Ideal for stimulating both the vagina and anus
  • It is not a heavy plug – you can wear it anywhere
  •  Modest 2.5-inch length makes it easy to insert for beginners

CONS: 

  • Can’t be used with silicone lube

What is a Butt Plug and Why Should You Care?

There’s a bunch of reasons that butt plugs have become so popular lately, but here’s a few of the most prominent:

  • Increased sexual pleasure. Who doesn’t want that? These cool toys can be used for self- pleasure or during sex if you are a couple. Wearing a butt plug during sex (whether you’re a man or woman) can heighten the sensations of regular intercourse.
  • Some females use butt plugs for “double penetration”, allowing them to experience both their vagina and their butt being filled at the same time. Some women claim that this heightens their pleasure.
  • Anal orgasms can be reached with an anal plug, although this is more advanced-level butt plugging.
  • Men have a prostate (i.e. the male G spot) which a butt plug can help to stimulate, leading to very intense orgasms.

It is crucial that you keep pleasuring yourself (or yourselves) in a way that will let you stay safe. There are two factors that you need to consider when using a butt plug in a safe way:

  • The flared base is of huge importance if you don’t want accidents to happen. This will keep the toy reachable and you will be able to take it out. It’s there to stop the toy slipping inside of you as your butthole contracts and relaxes with pleasure! Do you really want to end up in hospital with a butt plug stuck up your ass? Probably not.
  • Another thing that you should be aware of when buying a butt plug is the material. You need to make sure the material that the toy is made off will not break inside you and cause damage. The most common materials are: proper annealed metalglass, silicone, stainless steel and even wood (although I wouldn’t recommend wood personally). Feeling comfortable is also very important.

How to use a butt plug?

As we all know, in anal sex you need a lot of lubricant, as the bottom doesn’t produce natural lubricant/fluid like the vagina or mouth. You can use silicone lubricant for toys that are not made from silicone and water-based lube for toys that are made from silicone. A little foreplay can definitely work, so try teasing your hole with your finger first, especially if you’re new to ass play or you’ve not been down there in a while.

You definitely need to be relaxed, feel good and get ready for this. After inserting one finger, you can introduce an additional one and when you feel that your hole is relaxed and large enough. Then you should try the toy.

How to clean a butt plug?

Cleaning is also very important. Nonporous materials are a great choice because they can be boiled to make sure there are no germs left. For some toys, however, warm water and soap should suffice. You should definitely not use a toy for vaginal pleasure after anal, however, as this could cause infections.

 It is also highly recommended not to pass your anal toy to somebody else. Do not, under any circumstances, share your butt plug with another man or woman, especially if you use it bare without a condom over the top of it. Generally speaking, your sex toys (butt plugs included) should be for your bum and your bum alone!

Summing Up

It seems like there’s a butt plug out there for everyone, whether you’re into vanilla butt plugs, elegant glass pineapples, or unicorn tails. It doesn’t matter if you decide to go for a medical-grade silicone plug or a toy made from something a little weirder (like stone); just make sure that you read the instructions, play safe, and use lots of the appropriate lubrication every time you use a butt plug. The anal passage cannot be treated the same way as a vagina, so be sure to bear that in mind as you start your bum fun journey!

>