Best Tail Butt Plugs

21 Best Tail Butt Plugs for Sexy Roleplay Ideas

From furry sex to slutty Halloween costumes, animal roleplay has always found its way into the bedroom.

It makes sense really – cats have a sexy feline elegance, bunnies are adorably cute, and puppies naturally have a BDSM-like master-slave relationship with their owner.

A butt plug with a tail allows you to embody a sexy animal, whether it’s a fox, a pony, or a Pikachu.

In this list, I look at 21 of the best animal butt plugs on the market, covering ALL the major animal tail sex toys and price points you’ll come across.

Let’s dive in!

21 Sexy Animal Tail Butt Plugs

Traditional Fox Tail Butt Plug (Real Fur)

Feeling foxy?

If you wanna rock a sexy fox costume with the classic red/brown tail, look no further than this charming Etsy butt plug! The plugs can be metal or silicone and come in different sizes, so it’s easy to find a fit that suits you. This tail is 20 inches long, so it’s very big, making it perfect for realistic roleplay.

Traditional Fox Tail Butt Plug

Some anal tail plugs are made with real fur, so if you live a vegan lifestyle or don’t like the idea of wearing real fur, keep an eye out for that. There are plenty of faux fur options available – most of the tails in this list are fake fur.

Bunny Tail Butt Plug

Hop into bed and breed like rabbits!

Want to live your Bridget Jones Playboy Bunny fantasy? This bunny buttplug from Crystal Delights actually won the XBIZ Adult Award for “Best Non-Powered Pleasure Product” in 2013. The 2.8-inch Pyrex glass buttplug can be warmed up or cooled down in water for temperature play, and the tail is actually magnetic, so you can play with or without the bunny tail.

Bunny Tail Butt Plug

Silver Fox Tail Anal Plug

Unleash your silver fox. Helen Mirren is shook

This dazzling faux fur buttplug is 18.5 inches long and has a lovely soft feel to it that’s sure to get your pulse racing. The lightweight steel anal plug is 2.5 inches long and weighs just 95 grams, so it’s brilliant for animal tail newbies who aren’t used to wearing larger and heavier tail plugs.

Silver Fox Tail Anal Plug

Pink Unicorn Butt Plug

It doesn’t get much campier than this

While it’s not the largest or longest animal tail in the world, this bright pink silicone butt plug is perfect for bringing a little dazzle and theatricality to the bedroom! This tapered buttplug could work brilliantly for My Little Pony roleplay or dressing up as a full-blown sexy unicorn. It even comes with a bottle of water-based lube included. How thoughtful.

Pink Unicorn Butt Plug

I love the wonderfully wholesome product description – “unicorn tails are perfect for kinky cosplay with a partner or to ride alone into the sunset”.

Glass Buttplug with Fake Fur Tail

Perfect for pet play

This 11-inch-long fake fur tail could be used to play various animals, though I think it makes a great feline tail toy personally. The glass plug is 4 inches long and is made from reinforced glass which is designed to be heat-resistant and shatter-resistant. The tip of this large anal toy is tapered for easy insertion, making your sexy roleplay easy breezy.

Glass Buttplug with Fake Fur Tail

Silicone Puppy Tail Plug

Bad dog!

Fans of pup play will really appreciate this extra-large silicone puppy tail plug from Master Series. The plug on this toy is EXTREMELY large, so it’s best suited to experienced puppy play fans, but you can buy smaller versions too. Because this toy is 100% silicone, it’s really easy to clean the whole tail and even sanitize it via bleaching or boiling.

Silicone Puppy Tail Plug

Buttplugs are fun and all that, but you gotta know how to clean sex toys efficiently too. Suffice it to say that UTIs are not fun.

Pom Pom Butt Plug

Go team! Go team! Go team!

This fun little pom pom buttplug is made from platinum-cured silicone, which is about as high-quality as silicone gets in the sex toy world. It has 3.5 inches of insertable length and is fairly slim, so it’s an intermediate-level kinda plug. Maybe you could pretend to be a slutty cheerleader who’s just shoved her pom pom up her butt? Let me hear you say this shit is bananas!

Pom Pom Butt Plug

Small Aluminum Fake Fur Bunny Plug

You’ve got a rabbit vibrator, why not a rabbit tail?

Okay, so we’ve already had a bunny tail on this list, but this version has an aluminum butt plug. The metal buttplug has 3.5 inches of insertable length, so it’s maybe best suited to beginners and intermediate roleplayers. This bunny tail is also 100% super soft fake fur, so you needn’t feel guilty about wearing real animal products if that’s not your jam.

Small Aluminum Fake Fur Bunny Plug

As a UK native, saying “aluminum” really pains me.

Glass Curly Fake Pony Butt Plug

Brilliant for pony play!

This sexy glass butt plug with tail is 3 inches long and 4 inches in girth, so it’s a pretty large buttplug in terms of thickness. The bouncy fake fur ponytail is around 16 inches long and adorably soft – just make sure that you brush it every now and then to keep it looking good. The realistic size of this plug is ideal for pony sex play.

Glass Curly Fake Pony Butt Plug

I like the idea of roleplaying as Lil’ Sebastian and having everyone make a fuss over me. He’s a little horse, of course, not a pony.

Stainless Steel Fake Fur Anal Plug

Big, black, and bushy. What more do you want?

This black furry tail buttplug is perfect for many animal-based roleplays, such as puma, fox, and dog scenes. It’s made from soft fake fur and is 12 inches long. The stainless steel plug has 4 inches of insertable length and features a skinny neck, allowing your anus to fully close around the plug and hold it in place well. At 420g, this weighty plug is great for mid-level roleplay!

Stainless Steel Fake Fur Anal Plug

Dragon Tail Buttplug

Who doesn’t want to be a dirty dirty slut dragon?

Available with a metal or silicone plug, this awesome dragon tail plug is half-wired, so you can pose it in different sexy positions as you please. There are 30-inch and 40-inch size options available, so these butt plug tail toys are EXTREMELY LONG. I’m not personally keen on the fur for a dragon tail (I prefer scales) but everyone’s aesthetics are different.

Dragon Tail Buttplug

Cow Tail Plug

Are you in the moooooo-d? … I’ll see myself out.

Coming with metal, silicone, or clip-on anal plugs according to your preference, this fun cow anal plug is 25 inches long and made from 100% fake fur and synthetic materials. Have you always fantasized about being “milked” by your partner? Well, now you can bring that fantasy to life!

Cow Tail Plug

Cat Tail Buttplug

The purrrrrr-fect plug

Cat tails come in all different colors and sizes depending on the breed of cat, but I’m a big fan of this gorgeous grey, black, and white bushy cat tail anal plug on Etsy. The 21-inch real fox fur product can be attached to a metal plug, silicone plug, or a clip-on attachment depending on your preference. Meow!

Cat Tail Buttplug

Pig Tail Butt Plug

Now this is one sexy sty!

Handmade from premium pink silicone, these pig butt tail plugs are brilliant for oinking around and getting mucky in the boudoir! There are 4 different size options available, ranging from 3.1 inches of insertable length (small) to 4.6 inches of insertable length (large). There’s also a lifetime replacement warranty for added peace of mind.

Pig Tail Butt Plug

Rose Crystal Princess Plug

Feel like a princess. A princess who take it up the ass.

I didn’t think you could describe a buttplug as “opulent”, but here we are. This gorgeous princess plug comes with a genuine pink Swarovski element, instilling your anal play and butt plug training with a sense of class and sophistication. It’s also available in many different bulb sizes and stem lengths, so it’s perfect for princesses of all shapes, sizes, and experience levels.

Rose Crystal Princess Plug

Yes, I know that it’s not technically a “tail” butt plug, but I’m including a couple extra plugs that I think are pretty. Sue me.

Pikachu Buttplug and Ears

I choose you!

You might have heard of Pokémon porn… well now you buy a Pikachu buttplug to go with your sexy Pikachu costume. This Pikachu tail is around 21 inches long and is stuffed with a wire frame so that it keeps the famous “lightning bolt” shape of this electric Pokémon’s tail. It also comes with 2 plug size options, both of which are high-quality silicone!

Pikachu Buttplug and Ears

All that time I spent playing Pokémon Blue in the ‘90s has affected me in a very… profound way.

Unicorn Medallion Glass Buttplug

It’s glorious

If you want to feel majestic but a full-on tail isn’t quite for you, how about this cute magnetic glass buttplug complete with bedazzled graphic on the base? There are 6 different size options available, from 2.8 inches of insertable length to 3.7 inches, and you can get various bulb thicknesses too.

Unicorn Medallion Glass Buttplug

Glass sex toys are usually made from borosilicate glass, a special kind of reinforced glass designed to withstand heat and shattering. It’s similar to the stuff used in Pyrex casserole dishes and kitchen jugs.

MPL Anal Plug (My Little Pony buttplug)

Friendship is magic!

These are some of the nicest furry anal plugs I’ve ever seen in my life! The steep price sure reflects that, but anyone into MLP play really needs to invest in these awesome colorful tails. There are 6 color options to choose from – lavender, pink, rainbow, blue, yellow, and pastel rainbow. All of the tails are handmade in the USA and come attached to high-quality glass bulbs.

MPL Anal Plug

Red Heart Glass Anal Plug

Open up your heart (or butthole).

Another sexy toy made by Crystal Delights, this cute anal plug features a dazzling red heart made from glittering rhinestones. Attached via magnets, this unique sex toy is available in 6 different sizes so suit different bodies and experience levels. Again, this one isn’t a tail, but it’s pretty and I still think it’s cool. Sue me!

Red Heart Glass Anal Plug

Wolf Butt Plug

You’ll definitely have a full moon (get it?)

You’ve heard of hungry like the wolf, but what about horny like the wolves? This grey buttplug and ears set makes the perfect sexy wolf costume for adventurous couples experimenting with roleplay ideas. The fake fur tail is an impressive 19 inches long, while the silicone plug is a hefty 4 inches long despite being very slim.

Wolf Butt Plug

This product comes with matching ears and everything. Pop ‘em on and get straight into character. Channel your inner Michael J. Fox.

Randy Raccoon Buttplug

Maybe you could join Coon and Friends in your spare time.

Raccoons are mischievous animals, which makes them perfect for naughty anal roleplay! This racoon tail anal plug is fairly small and lightweight, measuring a mere 11 inches long, but it’s a fun way to spice things up in the bedroom nonetheless. The high-grade steel plug is 2.5 inches in insertable length and boasts a skinny neck, helping your anus to close around the plug and keep it in place.

Randy Raccoon Buttplug

Cum-clusion

Cum-clusion. Best tail butt plugs

I hope you enjoyed this guide to the best animal butt plugs! From basic fox tails to naughty Pikachu tail plugs, we’ve taken a look at dozens of anal toys that help to spice up your animal roleplay while keeping your anus nice and plugged up.

Before play, make sure to use plenty of anal lubricant with your toy (avoid silicone-based lubes if your plug is silicone) and start small before working your way up to the larger plugs.

Have fun, stay safe, and try not to break character!

About The Author ~ J.C. Way


I’ve never been afraid to stick things up my butt or pop my cock into something – why wouldn’t you want to make your sex life better? I aim to smash down stigmas and introduce men and women to sex toys that change their lives.

>